Front. Public HealthFrontiers in Public HealthFront. Public Health2296-2565Frontiers Media S.A.10.3389/fpubh.2023.1095916Public HealthOriginal ResearchComparison of copper concentration between non-alcoholic fatty liver disease patients and normal individuals: A meta-analysisChenYanfang1†WuChutian1†LiGuanhong1WangWen2TangShaohui1*1Department of Gastroenterology, The First Affiliated Hospital, Jinan University, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China2Department of Gastroenterology, Guangdong General Hospital's Nanhai Hospital, Foshan, China
Edited by: Chunguang Yang, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, China
Reviewed by: Aaron Koenig, The Ohio State University, United States; Zhuang Zhang, Anhui Medical University, China
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is the most prevalent chronic liver disease worldwide. Copper metabolism plays an important role in the pathogenesis of NAFLD. However, the relationship between serum/hepatic copper concentration and NAFLD is still debated. A literature search was performed using electronic databases to find publications up to September 2022, where the relationship between serum/hepatic copper or ceruloplasmin concentration and NAFLD was evaluated. Finally, 6 articles with 9 unique outcomes involving 2,607 NAFLD patients and 1,441 non-NAFLD normal individuals were included. The pooled results showed that hepatic copper concentration was significantly decreased in NAFLD patients (SMD = −0.98, 95% CI = [−1.21; −0.74], p < 0.0001), and the sensitivity analysis also confirmed this. Nevertheless, serum copper (SMD = −0.02, 95% CI = [−0.32; 0.28], p = 0.88) and ceruloplasmin (SMD = −0.03, 95% CI = [−0.69; 0.63], p = 0.93) were not associated with NAFLD. This meta-analysis revealed that low hepatic copper concentration was found in NAFLD patients and serum copper and ceruloplasmin were not associated with NAFLD. Larger cohort studies and related trials are needed to further validate the result of this meta-analysis in the future.
non-alcoholic fatty liver diseasecopperserumhepaticmeta-analysisA2019256Medical Science and Technology Foundation of Guangdong Province10.13039/501100009330Introduction
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is a multistage disease affecting 30% of the global population, which will supposedly emerge as the most common cause of the end-stage liver disease (1, 2). Substantial studies have demonstrated that NAFLD contributes to several disease processes containing hepatic/extrahepatic diseases and an overall increase in mortality (3). Currently, it is well recognized that the double-hit theory plays a vital role in the pathogenesis of NAFLD (4). However, no medicine is consented yet for this condition by the US Food and Drug Administration or the European Medicines Agency (5).
Serum copper is mainly transported by binding to ceruloplasmin which regulates the distribution and release of copper and later played its biological roles (6). Copper is an indispensable trace element that serves as a structural and enzymatic cofactor for various antioxidant proteins, including cytochrome c oxidase (COX), superoxide dismutase (SOD), and ceruloplasmin (7). Excessive or deficient copper can lead to mitochondrial dysfunction or dyslipidemia (8). A typical example is Wilson's disease, an overloaded hepatic copper accumulation and insufficient ceruloplasmin with liver steatosis, inflammation, and cuprotosis (9). However, recent studies demonstrate the association between copper deficiency and the accumulation of fat in the liver, and NAFLD patients with hepatic copper deficiency show more severe liver steatosis, inflammation, and clinical symptoms (10, 11). Besides, rats fed with a restricted copper diet will spontaneously develop liver steatosis (12). These results indicate that copper plays an essential role in the pathogenesis of NAFLD.
Whereas, the relationship between serum/hepatic copper levels and NAFLD is still unclear. What's more, it is reported that lower hepatic copper is associated with NAFLD, but excessive copper also impairs hepatocytes (8, 13). Lan, et al. find that blood copper concentration is lower in NAFLD patients (14). Chen, et al. and Wang, et al. indicate that serum copper level is higher in NAFLD patients compared with normal individuals (15, 16).
Given that the role of copper in NAFLD is still controversial, this study performed a meta-analysis of the studies on serum/hepatic copper or ceruloplasmin levels to clarify their relationship.
Materials and methodsData sources and search strategy
We searched Pubmed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and China National Knowledge Internet (CNKI) databases from inception to September 20, 2022. Key search terms included: (“NAFLD” or “fatty liver”) AND (“copper” or “cuprum” or “ceruloplasmin”). We also manually screened the citation of selected articles to identify the eligible articles. The present systematic review was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) checklist, and the protocol had been registered at PROSPERO (www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO, ID: CRD42022361187).
Study selection
Abstracts and titles were reviewed to filter out irrelevant studies. Potentially relevant studies had their full text extracted and two reviewers (Guanhong Li and Wen Wang) independently assessed articles for inclusion/exclusion criteria. Dissonance was resolved by discussion. Inclusion criteria included: (1) studies comparing serum copper or hepatic copper levels between NAFLD patients and non-NAFLD normal individuals (control group); (2) diagnosis of hepatic steatosis by imaging or biopsy; (3) full-text articles available. Exclusion criteria included: (1) studies using overlapping samples; (2) those did not contain non-NAFLD normal control; (3) researches about copper intake; (3) incomplete or unextractable raw data; (4) reviews, letters, case reports, editorials, conference abstracts, and animal experiments. A summary of studies identified, screening, eligibility, and exclusion is shown in the PRISMA flow diagram (Figure 1).
The PRISMA flow diagram of the study selection process.
Data extraction and quality assessment
Two reviewers (YF and CT) independently performed data extraction and solved dissonance by discussion. Data extracted for eligible studies included the first author, publication year, study location, study design, the diagnostics method of NAFLD, serum/hepatic copper levels or ceruloplasmin and standard deviation (SD), sample size, the method for the detection of copper, age, and sex.
Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale (NOS) was used to assess the methodological quality of included studies. Risk of bias was categorized as follows: 7–9 was regarded as high-quality, 4–6 as moderate-quality, and under 4 as low-quality (17).
Statistical analysis
All statistical analyses were performed using “meta” R package in R software (Version 4.2.1, www.r-project.org). Heterogeneity was evaluated using the χ2 test, tau2 test, and Higgins I2 test. If p value ≥ 0.05 and I2 ≤ 50%, suggesting little homogeneity among the studies, the fixed effect model was used for analysis. If p value < 0.05 and I2 > 50%, indicating substantial heterogeneity among different studies, the random effects model was used for analysis. If there was heterogeneity among the studies, subgroup analysis was conducted to detect the source of heterogeneity. Standardized mean differences (SMD) and a 95% confidence interval (CI) of serum/copper levels were calculated for continuous variables. A sensitivity analysis was performed by omitting one study and pooling the SMD for the others in each turn. Publication biases were determined by Egger's test. A p value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
ResultsStudy selection and characteristics
As shown in Figure 1, 2,436 articles were included in the initial research, and 6 articles with 9 unique outcomes were finally retrieved after filtration. The 9 researches were published from 2008 to 2022, involving 2,607 NAFLD patients and 1,441 non-NAFLD normal individuals (control group). One study was cross-sectional and 5 studies were case-control. Two studies were carried out in China, 2 in Austria, 1 in America, and 1 in Iran. The NOS scores shown that 3 studies were rated as high quality and 3 were considered as moderate quality (Table 1).
The characteristics of included study.
NAFLD
CNTR
Author
Country
year
Copper detection
Diagnostic method
Type
Study design
Age
Male/Female
Age
Male/Female
NOS
Arefhosseini. et al. (10)
Iran
2022
Commercial kits
US
SCu
Cross-sectional
37.07 ± 11.78
18/67
26.48 ± 13.19
19/37
6
Lan. et al. (14)
China
2021
ICP-MS
US
SCu
Case-control
56.3 ± 12.12
970/846
56.4 ± 12.3
598/513
9
Wang. et al. (16)
China
2011
FAAS
US
SCu
Case–control
39.13 ± 10.69
105/45
38.94 ± 10.66
105/45
7
Aigner. et al. (18)
Austria
2008
Laboratory methods
Biopsy
SCu
Case–control
52.4 ± 11.1
84/56
43.6 ± 9.3
8/16
6
Arefhosseini. et al. (10)
Iran
2022
Commercial kits
US
SCer
Cross-sectional
37.07 ± 11.78
18/67
26.48 ± 13.19
19/37
6
Mendoza. et al. (19)
America
2017
NA
Biopsy
SCer
Case–control
13.9 ± 3
77/25
13.4 ± 5
16/32
7
Mendoza. et al. (19)
America
2017
NA
Biopsy
HCu
Case–control
13.9 ± 3
77/25
13.4 ± 5
16/32
7
Stattermayer. et al. (13)
Austria
2017
FAAS
Biopsy
HCu
Case–control
49.1 ± 3
120/54
34.1
14/12
6
Aigner. et al. (18)
Austria
2008
MS
Biopsy
HCu
Case–control
52.4 ± 11.1
84/56
43.6 ± 9.3
8/16
6
The data were shown as mean ± standard deviation (SD). NAFLD, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease; CNTR, control group; ICP-MS, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry; FAAS, flame atomic absorption spectroscopy; MS, mass spectrometry; NA, not available; US, ultrasound; NOS, Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale; SCu, serum copper; SCer, serum ceruloplasmin; HCu, hepatic copper.
Overall meta-analysis
Meta-analysis was performed to compare the hepatic/serum copper or ceruloplasmin levels between NAFLD patients and the control group. There were 3 researches about hepatic copper and the heterogeneity among the studies was little (I2 = 19%, tau2 = 0.0076, p = 0.29). The hepatic copper level was significantly decreased in NALFD patients (SMD = −0.98, 95% CI = [−1.21; −0.74], p < 0.0001, Figure 2A) using the fixed effects model.
The forest plots for comparisons of hepatic copper (A), serum copper (B) and ceruloplasmin (C) between NAFLD and the control group. SD, standard deviation; SMD, standardized mean differences; CI, confidence interval.
Moreover, 4 studies contained serum copper levels and substantial heterogeneity was found among the studies (I2 = 81%, tau2 = 0.0734, p < 0.01). There was no significant relationship between serum copper and NAFLD (SMD = −0.02, 95% CI = [−0.32; 0.28], p = 0.88, Figure 2B) using the random effects model. Besides, 2 studies included serum ceruloplasmin and large heterogeneity was found among the studies (I2 = 87%, tau2 = 0.1976, p < 0.01). There was no significant relationship between serum ceruloplasmin and NAFLD (SMD = −0.03, 95% CI = [−0.69; 0.63], p = 0.93, Figure 2C) by the random effects model.
Sensitivity analysis and publication bias
Sensitivity analysis suggested that no single study significantly influenced the difference on hepatic copper (Figure 3A) and serum copper (Figure 3B) in the comparison between NAFLD patients and normal individuals. Also, Egger's test indicated that there was no publication bias in the pooled estimates of hepatic copper (p = 0.73), and serum copper (p = 0.65). Given only 2 studies about serum ceruloplasmin, the sensitivity analysis and publication bias were not performed in the comparison of serum ceruloplasmin.
The forest plots showing the sensitive analysis of hepatic (A) and serum copper (B). SMD, standardized mean differences; CI, confidence interval.
Discussion
This meta-analysis revealed that hepatic copper concentration was significantly decreased in NAFLD patients and the sensitivity analysis also confirmed this. Nevertheless, serum copper and ceruloplasmin were not associated with NAFLD.
The total copper content in the adult body is 50–120 mg, and balancing the concentration of copper in the liver is essential for biological processes (20). It is reported that downregulation of hepatic ceruloplasmin results in the restoration of hepatic copper level, which attenuates liver steatosis by targeting copper-SOC1-AMPK signaling pathway in NAFLD mice model (20). What's more, copper inhibits the activation of PDE3B, a key enzyme of lipolysis, and the latter promotes c-AMP-dependent lipolysis (21). In addition, excessive copper induces lipogenesis and lipolysis through the activation of Nrf2-PPARγ pathway and autophagy (22). Moreover, copper induces cell death by targeting the lipoylated components of the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, which is called “cuproptosis” (9). Obviously, the homeostasis of copper plays an important role in lipid metabolism. Given the different results between liver copper and serum copper in our study, the biological function of liver copper and serum copper may be varying, and a positive correlation is found between serum copper and hepatic copper concentration in NAFLD patients, but there is no research contributing to the difference biological function between them (18).
Our research had the following advantages: (1) this study was the first to conduct a meta-analysis of the relationship between copper and NAFLD. However, our research also had some disadvantages: (1) the included studies were mainly case-control and cross-sectional study; (2) the meta-analysis of serum copper concentration still had substantial heterogeneity, and the removal of any literature did not improve this; (3) as few literatures on copper and NAFLD at present, few literatures were included; (4) the measurements used varied among the included studies, which increased the heterogeneity; (5) there was a strong possibility of sampling bias in our study. The liver copper cases were predominantly male (only 32% of subjects were female in the subset of studies with liver tissue data) which was not representative. Further, it was unclear what the severity of the disease was in the included studies (as an invasive test, people who were biopsied might have increased pre-test probability of more severe disease). According to Mendoza et al., advanced fibrosis may increase hepatic copper concentrations, which was part of the reason why that study excluded patients with high liver tissue copper (19); (6) we were unable to address the competing etiologies of copper deficiency and excess; (7) in the liver tissue studies, there are few controls for comparison, in part because of the invasive biopsy procedure required.
Therefore, this study suggests that the hepatic copper concentration is significantly decreased in NAFLD patients, and no difference is found in serum copper and ceruloplasmin between NAFLD patients and the normal individuals. Larger cohort studies and related trials are needed to further validate the result of this meta-analysis in the future.
Author contributions
YC and CW contributed equally to this paper. YC, CW, and GL were involved with the study concept and design, acquisition of data, analysis, interpretation of data, drafting of the manuscript, and critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content. WW was involved in the acquisition of data. ST supervised the research and edited the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.
Funding
This research was supported by the Medical Science and Technology Research Fund of Guangdong Province, China (No. A2019256).
The authors appreciate the study investigators and staff who participated in this study.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Publisher's note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
ReferencesUpchurchCMYeudallSPavelecCMMerkDGreulichJManjegowdaM. Targeting oxidized phospholipids by AAV-based gene therapy in mice with established hepatic steatosis prevents progression to fibrosis. Sci Adv. (2022) 8:eabn0050. 10.1126/sciadv.abn005035857497WuCZhouYWangMDaiGLiuXLaiL. Bioinformatics analysis explores potential hub genes in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Front Genet. (2021) 12:772487. 10.3389/fgene.2021.77248734777484ZhongLWuCLiYZengQLaiLChenS. Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and health outcomes: An umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Ther Adv Chronic Dis. (2022) 13:20406223221083508. 10.1177/2040622322108350835623903LazarusJVMarkHEVillota-RivasMPalayewACarrieriPColomboM. Anstee: The global NAFLD policy review and preparedness index: Are countries ready to address this silent public health challenge?J. Hepatol. (2022) 76:771–80. 10.1016/j.jhep.2021.10.02534895743LiJLiYFengSHeKGuoLChenW. Differential effects of dietary white meat and red meat on NAFLD progression by modulating gut microbiota and metabolites in rats. Oxid Med Cell Longev. (2022) 2022:6908934. 10.1155/2022/690893436035222TianSJonesSMSolomonEI. Role of a tyrosine radical in human ceruloplasmin catalysis. ACS Cent Sci. (2020) 6:1835–43. 10.1021/acscentsci.0c0095333145420ChimientiGOrlandoARussoFD'attomaBAragnoMAimarettiE. The mitochondrial trigger in an animal model of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Genes. (2021) 12:1439. 10.3390/genes1209143934573421MaCHanLZhuZHengPCPanG. Mineral metabolism and ferroptosis in non-alcoholic fatty liver diseases. Biochem Pharmacol. (2022) 205:115242. 10.1016/j.bcp.2022.11524236084708TsvetkovPCoySPetrovaBDreishpoonMVermaAAbdusamadM. Copper induces cell death by targeting lipoylated TCA cycle proteins. Science. (2022) 375:1254–61. 10.1126/science.abf052936356160ArefhosseiniSPouretedalZTutunchiHEbrahimi-MameghaniM. Serum copper, ceruloplasmin, and their relations to metabolic factors in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease: a cross-sectional study. Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol. (2022) 34:443–8. 10.1097/MEG.000000000000232534860704AignerEStrasserMHaufeHSonnweberTHohlaFStadlmayrA. A role for low hepatic copper concentrations in non-alcoholic Fatty liver disease. Am J Gastroenterol. (2010) 105:1978–85. 10.1038/ajg.2010.17020407430SongMSchuschkeDAZhouZChenTPierceWJWangR. High fructose feeding induces copper deficiency in Sprague-Dawley rats: a novel mechanism for obesity related fatty liver. J Hepatol. (2012) 56:433–40. 10.1016/j.jhep.2011.05.03021781943StattermayerAFTraussniggSAignerEKienbacherCHuber-SchonauerUSteindl-MundaP. Low hepatic copper content and PNPLA3 polymorphism in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease in patients without metabolic syndrome. J Trace Elem Med Biol. (2017) 39:100–7. 10.1016/j.jtemb.2016.08.00627908400LanYWuSWangYChenSLiaoWZhangX. Association between blood copper and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease according to sex. Clin Nutr. (2021) 40:2045–52. 10.1016/j.clnu.2020.09.02633039155ChenCZhouQYangRWuZYuanHZhangN. Copper exposure association with prevalence of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and insulin resistance among US adults (NHANES 2011-2014). Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. (2021) 218:112295. 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2021.11229533962276JikaiWZheweiFQingyanLYingchunL. Relationship between copper nutrition and blood lipid in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (in Chinese). Chronic Dis Prevent Control China. (2011) 19:346–7.StangA. Critical evaluation of the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for the assessment of the quality of non-randomized studies in meta-analyses. Eur J Epidemiol. (2010) 25:603–5. 10.1007/s10654-010-9491-z20652370AignerETheurlIHaufeHSeifertMHohlaFScharingerL. Copper availability contributes to iron perturbations in human non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Gastroenterology. (2008) 135:680–8. 10.1053/j.gastro.2008.04.00718505688MendozaMCaltharpSSongMCollinLKonomiJVMcClainCJ. Low hepatic tissue copper in pediatric non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. (2017) 65:89–92. 10.1097/MPG.000000000000157128644356XieLYuanYXuSLuSGuJWangY. Downregulation of hepatic ceruloplasmin ameliorates NAFLD via SCO1-AMPK-LKB1 complex. Cell Rep. (2022) 41:111498. 10.1016/j.celrep.2022.11149836261001KrishnamoorthyLCotruvoJJChanJKaluarachchiHMuchenditsiAPendyalaVS. Copper regulates cyclic-AMP-dependent lipolysis. Nat Chem Biol. (2016) 12:586–92. 10.1038/nchembio.209827272565ZhongCCZhaoTHogstrandCChenFSongCCLuoZ. Copper (Cu) induced changes of lipid metabolism through oxidative stress-mediated autophagy and Nrf2/PPARgamma pathways. J Nutr Biochem. (2022) 100:108883. 10.1016/j.jnutbio.2021.10888334653601