Developmental dysplasia disease of the hip (DDDH) consists of hip alterations, ranging from a slight incongruence between the articular surfaces to the dislocation of the femoral head outside the acetabulum (1). DDDH originates from the interaction between the cartilage maturation, bony elements of the acetabulum, and the pressure applied by muscular forces on the femoral head (2).

In the USA, DDDH occurs in 1 in 100 live births in the form of instability and in 1 in 1,000 live births in the form of hip dislocation (3). In Mexico, 1% of neonates have DDDH, and 75% of macrosomia infants at birth have ultrasonographic evidence of hip abnormalities. Nevertheless, only 1 in every 7,000 live births progresses to hip dislocation (4). Fernandez (5) pointed out that 17% of affected children were diagnosed by the medical doctor and the rest by the family, generally in the second semester of the infant's life, when the infant started walking.

The cause of DDDH may include maternal hormones, macrosomia, breech presentation with extension of the lower extremities, inadequate obstetric practices during birth and in postnatal life, and improper wrapping or carrying techniques for the baby (6, 7). DDDH is classified into physiological immaturity, subluxation, luxation, and dislocation of the hip. The clinical diagnosis is established through procedures that should be routinely performed during the examination of neonates and infants: Ortolani, Barlow, Peter–Baden, and limitation of abduction, among others (1). These procedures only detect hips with subluxation, luxation, or dislocation (1, 6, 7), and physiological immaturity may go undiagnosed, potentially becoming a risk factor for progression to subluxation, luxation, or dislocation.

In 1987, Stone et al. (8) described sound transmission testing with a tuning fork and stethoscope for clinical diagnosis, which was later replicated by Padilla-Raygoza and Figueroa-Ferrari (9) in Mexico, utilizing the properties of bone to transmit sound. The definitive diagnosis is made in neonates and infants up to 3 months of age, using the Graf technique in ultrasonography. Radiographs are not recommended in children under 8–12 weeks of postnatal life due to the incomplete ossification of the femoral head. This study aimed to compare the validity and reliability of sound transmission tests with a tuning fork and stethoscope with the usual clinical procedures for the diagnosis of DDDH in neonates from Guanajuato, Mexico.

The protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee for Research of Hospital General Salamanca (registry number CEI-HGS007-2023) on 13 March 2023.

The sample size was 100. Table 1 presents their sociodemographic characteristics. Males neonates comprised 56% of the sample and female neonates 44%; 65% of the all newborns were born via vaginal delivery. The average age at first contact after birth was 0.79 ± 0.71 days, and the average gestational age based on the last menstrual period was 39.22 ± 1.55 weeks.

According to the hip ultrasound using the Graf technique, the results predominantly showed physiological immaturity: 13% in the right hip and 17% in the left hip. Only two cases of subluxation and two cases of hip dislocation were detected (Table 2).

When comparing the three assessments using sound transmission and hip ultrasound with the Graf technique, the sensitivity was similar, at over 80%, specificity exceeded 90%, the positive predictive value ranged between 70% and 80%, and the negative predictive value was above 90% (Table 3).

The Ortolani procedure is used to diagnose subluxated or dislocated hips; however, it does not detect dysplasia. As shown in Table 4, the sensitivity was below 20% and the positive predictive value was under 50%.

For the Barlow maneuver, a similar issue arises as with the Ortolani maneuver. As it does not detect hip dysplasia and only identifies subluxated or dislocated hips, the sensitivity and positive predictive value were very low across the three measurements (Table 5).

Fold asymmetry is a sign that raises suspicion of subluxation or dislocation of the hip. However, there is no evidence that it indicates hip dysplasia, as demonstrated by the very low sensitivities (<10%) and positive predictive values of 50% or less (Table 6).

The intra-observer reliability was K = 0.89 and the inter-observer reliability was K = 0.85, indicating that the sound transmission test measurements were applied similarly by both the pediatrician and the pediatric resident (Table 7).

The intra-observer reliability of the Ortolani maneuver was 0.70, but the inter-observer reliability was much lower (0.54) (Table 8).

The Barlow maneuver showed a good intra-observer reliability of 0.80 (measurements made by the pediatrician), but the inter-observer reliability decreased to 0.62 (Table 9). Fold asymmetry showed an intra-observer reliability of 0.89. A comparison of the measurement by the pediatrician with that of the pediatric resident yielded a Kappa of 0.49 (Table 10).

In the sample of 100 neonates, 33 abnormal hips were detected (15 right hips and 18 left hips) (Table 2). It is important to note that, among the 100 newborns, 13 cases of right physiological immaturity and 17 cases of left subluxation were detected, along with 1 case of right subluxation, 1 case of right dislocation, and 1 case of left dislocation. Dislocation has been reported to occur in 1:1,000 births (3). The 30% incidence of physiological immaturity observed is similar to the rates reported in Mexico (7). In the USA, the prevalence of immaturity is 1% (3).

The sample for the present report consisted of newborns from a public hospital in Guanajuato City. The samples from other studies on the transmission of sound in the state of Guanajuato presented the following characteristics. In the first study in Celaya (9), the sample comprised 104 newborns and children aged up to 2 years from private healthcare institutions. The gold standard was the AP radiography in the neutral position and abduction. The results included 32 true positives (30.77%) and 11 false positives. The second sample comprised 150 newborns and children aged up to 28 days (7). In this case, the participants came from a public institution in Celaya. The gold standard was the Graf technique applied to hip ultrasounds. The results included 54% of the cases with physiological immaturity, 4.6% with subluxation, and none with luxation.

Regarding the sociodemographic variables across the mentioned samples, there were no differences between the mentioned samples. In addition, the frequencies of physiological immaturity, subluxation, or luxation were similar.

The sound transmission test showed superior validity and reliability than standard clinical procedures. Stone et al. (8) did not calculate the validity of the sound transmission test. Nevertheless, based on the published data, a sensitivity value of 72% and specificity of 88% can be computed, which are lower than those obtained in this research (Table 2). Validity demonstrates that the sound transmission should be measured for alterations of the hip, compared with the gold standard. In children up to 2 years of age from Celaya, the sensitivity was 74.4% and the specificity was 96.9% (9), which were slightly different from those obtained in this sample (Table 2).

Padilla and Figueroa (7) obtained a sensitivity of 86.36%, a specificity of 87.09%, a negative predictive value of 90.47%, and a negative predictive value of 81.81%, applying the sound transmission test. In this study, the sensitivity was 84.85%–87.88% in the three measurements (Table 3).

The tuning fork reliability for the sound transmission test was greater than 0.80 for both intra- and inter-observer comparisons (Table 6). Reliability shows that the results are similar independently of who applies the test; a kappa higher than 0.8 is excellent reliability. Reliability remains high in different observers because it is a simple test.

The clinical procedures of Ortolani, Barlow, and fold asymmetry only detect subluxation or dislocation. As they do not detect dysplasia, the validity for DDDH is very low, as demonstrated in this study (Tables 4, 5, and 6) and reported by Padilla and Figueroa (7). Dysplasia is much more prevalent than subluxation or dislocation. The validity and reliability values are low as the clinical procedures included in the study do not detect dysplasia.

Concerning more objective measures, the change in logarithm based on 10 of decibels (log₁₀dB), when comparing the transmission of sound with the extended vs. flexed legs, was measured using the electroacoustic probe. The difference in log_10dB detected was from −1.4 (false positives) to 3.1 in hips without alterations. For those with physiological immaturity, the difference was from −2.8 to 1.4 (false negatives). Finally, for subluxation, the difference of log₁₀dB was −1, and for luxation, it was −0.1 (12, 13). If dysplasia of the hip is not detected early, it can progress into subluxation or dislocation. Moreover, if children begin to walk while having this disease, they will need surgery on the hip.

Sound transmission with a tuning fork and stethoscope is a valuable tool for the diagnosis of DDDH in neonates. It aids in assessing the clinical suspicion of DDDH, which is confirmed through hip ultrasound using the Graf technique. The clinical procedures of Ortolani, Barlow, and Peter–Baden are effective at diagnosing subluxation or the dislocation of the hip. The sound transmission test serves as an additional tool for clinical diagnosis.

It is advisable to conduct studies with larger sample sizes. One of our future projects aims to include more newborns from the state of Guanajuato. This study demonstrated an optional, validated, and reliable tool for the diagnosis of DDDH in newborns.