Front. Microbiol.Frontiers in MicrobiologyFront. Microbiol.1664-302XFrontiers Media S.A.10.3389/fmicb.2023.1210790MicrobiologyOriginal ResearchPreparation and application of Ag plasmon Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst for removal of emerging contaminants under visible lightLongZeqing1†GuoTingting2†ChenChao2ZhangGuangming3*ZhuJia4*1Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Changzhi Medical College, Changzhi, China2Heping Hospital Affiliated to Changzhi Medical College, Changzhi, China3School of Energy & Environmental Engineering, Hebei University of Technology, Tianjin, China4School of Materials and Environmental Engineering, Shenzhen Polytechnic, Shenzhen, China
Edited by: Huike Dong, Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS), China
Reviewed by: Hongbiao Du, Tsinghua University, China; Hongliang Wang, Hubei University of Science and Technology, China; Yuanzhi Hong, Beihua University, China; Huinan Che, Hohai University, China
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
Photocatalytic degradation has been extensively investigated toward the removal emerging contaminants (ECs) from water. In this study, a series of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts were synthesized through the photo-deposition of metallic Ag on the Bi3O4Cl surface. The effects of plasmon modification on the catalytic performance of bismuth oxychlorides were analyzed. Ag addition did not alter the morphology of Bi3O4Cl. With the increasing Ag content, the number of oxygen defects on the catalyst surface first increased and then decreased. Moreover, the surface plasmon resonance effect of Ag suppressed the recombination of electron–hole pairs, promoting the migration and separation of photocarriers and improving the light absorption efficiency. However, the addition of excessive Ag reduced the number of active sites on the Bi3O4Cl surface, hindering the catalytic degradation of pollutants. The optimal Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst (Ag ratio: 0.025; solution pH: 9; dosage: 0.8 g/L) achieved 93.8 and 94.9% removal of ciprofloxacin and tetrabromobisphenol A, respectively. The physicochemical and photoelectric properties of Ag-Bi3O4Cl were determined through various characterization techniques. This study demonstrates that introducing metallic Ag alters the electron transfer path of the catalyst, reduces the recombination rate of electron–hole pairs, and effectively improves the catalytic efficiency of Bi3O4Cl. Furthermore, the pathways of ciprofloxacin degradation products and their biotoxicity were revealed.
Pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) and endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) are representative of emerging contaminants (ECs) that possess a bioaccumulation tendency and non-degradability (Liu et al., 2021; Wang et al., 2021); They are harmful to the nervous system of humans and other organisms, affect the function of the endocrine system, and endanger the reproductive capacity of humans and animals (Zhao et al., 2018). Ciprofloxacin (CIP), as a typical PPCP, has been widely used as a broad-spectrum antibiotic. Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) is the most industrially consumed flame retardant and considered as an EDC (Law et al., 2006; Klein et al., 2020). The complete removal of these pollutants through conventional water treatment processes is difficult (Morin-Crini et al., 2022). Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop new and efficient processes for the removal of these ECs from water.
Photocatalytic technology has attracted increasing attention in recent years owing to its sustainability and high contaminant mineralization rate (Long et al., 2020a). Previous studies have shown that photocatalytic technology can effectively remove ECs from water (Jiang et al., 2019). However, traditional photocatalysts (such as TiO2 and ZnO) have low solar light harvest efficiency and high charge recombination rate, limiting their activities and EC removal performance (Long et al., 2020b). Therefore, developing new and efficient visible-light-driven photocatalysts is necessary.
Recently, photocatalysts based on bismuth oxychlorides (BiOCl, Bi3O4Cl, Bi12O17Cl2, and Bi24O31Cl10) have been extensively studied (Xinping et al., 2006; Cui et al., 2016; Chang et al., 2017). The distinctive layered structure of bismuth oxychlorides is favorable to form an internal electric field, thereby accelerating electron–hole pair separation and imparting excellent optoelectronic properties (Long et al., 2020c). Researchers have worked extensively on modifying bismuth oxychlorides to further enhance their photocatalytic activities. Plasmon modification is currently one of the most important methods for catalyst modification (Zhang et al., 2019). Its principle is to exploit the plasmon resonance effect of noble metals to form a Schottky barrier on the interface with the catalyst, thus accelerating charge transfer, promoting electron–hole pairs separation, and enhancing light absorption by the catalyst. In addition, the increased current density can heat the metal particles, thereby accelerating the photochemical reaction (Hou et al., 2011). Yu et al. (2013) reported a series of (Rh, Pd, Pt)-BiOCl plasmon photocatalysts exhibiting excellent photocatalytic performance in visible light because the plasmon resonance generated by the noble metal nanoparticles improved the charge separation efficiency through electron capture. Xu et al. (2019) prepared a novel Ag@BiOCl plasmon photocatalyst, wherein the Schottky barrier formed by the BiOCl semiconductor and Ag nanoparticles served as a photoelectron capture center to to separate the photogenerated charges. Hence, the photocatalytic performance of the bismuth-oxychloride-based system was significantly improved through plasmon modification.
According to previous studies, among various bismuth-oxychloride-based photocatalysts, Bi3O4Cl has a more positive oxidation potential to oxidize pollutants, and its bandgap is suitable for visible-light-driven photocatalysis (Long et al., 2022a). Moreover, Bi3O4Cl has a desirable oxygen defect concentration to accelerate electron–hole pair separation (Cui et al., 2018). Therefore, Bi3O4Cl was used as the base material in this study, and relatively low-cost metallic Ag was used for plasmon modification. The performance of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst toward the removal of CIP and TBBPA was evaluated. A series of characterization techniques to analyze the physicochemical and photoelectric properties of the photocatalyst were conducted in order to reveal the modification and electron migration mechanisms. The results provide insights into the development of plasmon-modified bismuth oxychloride photocatalysts and their application in the removal of ECs from water.
2. Experimental2.1. Materials and methods
(Supplementary material).
2.2. Synthesis of Ag-Bi<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>Cl plasmonic photocatalysts
To synthesize the Bi3O4Cl nanoflakes, KCl (4 mmol) powder and deionized water (60 ml) were added to a 200 ml beaker. Subsequently, Bi(NO3)3⋅5H2O (4 mmol) was added, and the mixture was thoroughly stirred for 30 min to obtain a white suspension. The suspension was ultrasonicated for 5 min to achieve a uniform dispersion. Next, a NaOH (1 mol/L) solution was added dropwise, and the pH of the suspension was adjusted to 12.0 upon vigorous stirring. Subsequently, the suspension was transferred to a 100 ml Teflon hydrothermal reactor and maintained at 160°C for 12 h. The precipitate was separated and washed three times with deionized water and ethanol. Finally, Bi3O4Cl nanoflakes were obtained by drying the product in an air oven at 80°C for 4 h.
To synthesize Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalysts, the prepared Bi3O4Cl nanoflakes (0.736 g, 1 mmol) and deionized water (60 ml) were placed in a beaker and stirred for 30 min. Then, the standard AgNO3 standard solution (0.01, 0.025, 0.05, and 0.1 mmol) was added, and the mixture was stirred for 2 h under a 500 W xenon lamp. Subsequently, the product was washed three times with water and alcohol and dried in an oven at 80°C for 4 h. The prepared photocatalysts were denoted as 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, and 0.1-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, wherein 0.01, 0.025, 0.05, and 0.1 represent the molar concentration of the AgNO3 solution.
2.3. Characterization
(Supplementary material).
2.4. Photocatalytic tests and data analysis
In this study, the catalytic activity of the catalyst was assessed by the photocatalytic decomposition of ECs. A certain amount of photocatalysts and CIP (50 ml; 10 mg/L) or TBBPA (50 ml; 10 mg/L) solution were added to a quartz reactor and sonicated for 30 s. Next, the quartz reactor was placed in a PCX50C Discover photocatalytic reaction system equipped with a 5 W white LED lamp as a visible light source (400 nm ≤ λ ≤ 800 nm, Perfect Light Co., Ltd., Beijing, China).
Before irradiation, the mixture of the photocatalyst and contaminant solution (CIP or TBBPA, 10 mg/L) in the quartz reactor was stirred under dark conditions for 30 min to achieve the adsorption–desorption equilibrium. Then, the light source was turned on, and samples were extracted at specific intervals using a syringe. Next, the extracted solution was filtered through a 0.22 μm nitrocellulose filter to remove the suspended catalyst. The CIP concentration was measured at 277 nm using a UH5300 UV-vis spectrometer (Hitachi), and the TBBPA concentration was measured at 209 nm using an LC 3000 HPLC system (Agilent Technology Co., Ltd., Santa Clara, CA, United States) with a Thermo Fisher C18 column. The mobile phase in the HPLC column was 0.1 % acetic acid aqueous solution (solution A) and methanol (solution B). The v/v ratio of solution A to B was 2:8. The flow rate was 1 ml/min, and the column temperature was 35°C.
The main active species generated in the photocatalytic process were investigated to determine the possible mechanism. Sodium oxalate (SO, 1 mmol/L), tert-butyl alcohol (TBA, 10 mmol/L), and benzoquinone (BQ, 1 mmol/L) were added to scavenge holes (h+), hydroxyl radicals (⋅OH), and superoxide radicals (⋅O2–), respectively (Bi et al., 2016).
All experiments were repeated three times, and the mean values were reported.
3. Results and discussion3.1. Characterization of photocatalysts3.1.1. Crystal structures and morphologies
The crystal structures of the catalysts were analyzed using X-ray diffraction (XRD). Figure 1 shows the XRD patterns of a series of Ag-Bi3O4Cl samples prepared with different Ag contents. The diffraction patterns of all Ag-Bi3O4Cl catalysts agree well with that of the monoclinic crystal Bi3O4Cl (JCPDS 36-0760). Compared with pure Bi3O4Cl, the peaks and lattice parameters of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl catalysts remain unchanged, confirming that Ag is deposited on the Bi3O4Cl surface rather than entering its lattice. In addition, the intensity ratio of the (600)/(411) peaks change slightly, suggesting that the Ag content can impact the preferred orientation and the crystallinity of Bi3O4Cl to a certain extent (Li J. et al., 2014). The diffraction peak of metallic Ag is not detected possibly because of its low content and good dispersion on the Bi3O4Cl surface. Moreover, no impurities or other phases are detected, indicating the high purity of the synthesized photocatalysts.
X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalysts with different ratios.
Figures 2A–D show the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalysts with different Ag loadings. All samples exhibit the nanoflake morphology identical to that of Bi3O4Cl, indicating that Ag addition does not change the morphology of Bi3O4Cl. However, the surfaces of the nanoflakes become rough with increasing Ag content, implying that their crystallinity has changed, consistent with the XRD results.
The SEM image and surface elements distribution of samples: (A–D) The SEM image of 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl–0.1-Ag-Bi3O4Cl. (E–I) The surface elements distribution of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl.
Figures 2E–I show the results of the energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) surface elemental analysis of the 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl. The spectra reveal that Bi, O, Cl, and Ag are uniformly distributed on the surface. This is consistent with the XRD results that Ag is not incorporated into the lattice of Bi3O4Cl but deposited on its surface. Moreover, the uniform elemental distribution facilitates the electron transfer in the photocatalytic degradation (Niu et al., 2020b).
To further investigate the crystal structure of Ag-Bi3O4Cl, 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl was selected as a representative sample for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis. As shown in Figure 3A, it exhibits a nanoflake shape, consistent with the SEM images. In Figure 3B, the lattice spacings of 0.2702 and 0.1561 nm correspond to the (220) and (105) crystal planes of Bi3O4Cl and Ag, respectively. These results agree with the XRD and SEM observations and demonstrate that Ag is deposited on the surface of Bi3O4Cl and does not dissolve in the lattice.
The TEM analysis of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl: (A) TEM image, (B) high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) of the sample.
The specific surface areas and porous structures of pure Bi3O4Cl and Ag-Bi3O4Cl with different Ag loadings are summarized in Table 1. As the Ag loading increases, the specific surface area and pore volume first increase and then decrease, with 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl exhibiting the maximum specific surface area (19.971 m2/g) and highest pore volume (0.083 cm3/g). These results indicate that adding an appropriate amount of Ag to Bi3O4Cl can increase the surface area and pore volume, thereby enhancing the adsorption capacity. As the adsorption capacity increases, more pollutants can accumulate on the surface. The larger the specific surface area, the more active components are exposed, promoting the catalytic degradation of organic pollutants (Niu et al., 2020a).
The BET surface areas, pore volume, and pore diameter of Bi3O4Cl, 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, and 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl.
Sample
SBET (m2/g)
Pore volume (cm3g–1)
Pore diameter (nm)
Bi3O4Cl
10.841
0.047
1.677
0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl
19.971
0.083
1.923
0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl
12.092
0.039
1.675
3.1.2. Chemical compositions and valence state
Figure 4 shows the chemical compositions and valence states of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts synthesized with different Ag ratios. As shown in Figure 4A, Bi, Cl, O, and C elements are found in all samples and no impurity peaks are observed. The characteristic peak of Ag is not detected for 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl because of its low Ag content. With the increasing Ag loading, this peak emerges in the spectra of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl and 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl.
The X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectra of photocatalysts: (A) survey; (B) Bi 4f; (C) O 1s; (D) Cl 2p; (E) Ag 3d.
Figure 4B shows the Bi 4f characteristic peaks of the samples. In pure Bi3O4Cl, two characteristic peaks at 159.3 eV and 164.6 eV were detected, corresponding to the Bi 4f5/2 and Bi 4f7/2 orbitals of the Bi trivalent chemical state, respectively (Zhang et al., 2020). In addition, with an increase in the Ag content, the diffraction peak shifted toward a low binding energy, indicating the presence of low-charged Bi ions at the external sites of the Bi3O4Cl nanosheet. Sun et al. (2019) reported similar observations, which were attributed to the introduction of Ag metal, leading to the generation of oxygen defects (Apelgren et al., 2019).
In Figure 4C, there are two characteristic peaks of O 1s at approximately 531.5–531.7 eV and 529.7–530.1 eV, corresponding to the O2– in oxygen-deficient regions and lattice oxygen, respectively (Long et al., 2022b). Moreover, the oxygen defect content first increased and then decreased with increasing Ag content, and the presence of oxygen defects promoted electron-hole pairs separation in the photocatalysts (Zou et al., 2021). The presence of oxygen defects was further confirmed using electron spin resonance (ESR). In Supplementary Figure 1, the oxygen vacancies increase with the introduction of metallic Ag.
In Figure 4D, the two characteristic peaks of Bi3O4Cl are at approximately 199.8 and 198.3 eV, corresponding to Cl 2p1/2 and Cl 2p3/2, respectively (Wang et al., 2019). The characteristic peak of Cl 2p corresponding to Ag-Bi3O4Cl exhibits a trend of transition from a low binding energy to a high binding energy. The shift and transition of the Cl 2p characteristic peak in Ag-Bi3O4Cl may be due to the change in the Cl-O distance caused by oxygen defects; similar results have been observed in the study of Bi-BiOI (Sun et al., 2019).
In Figure 4E, the presence of elemental Ag in the 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl and 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl samples can be clearly observed, with two characteristic peaks of Ag 3d at approximately 373.9 and 367.8 eV, corresponding to Ag 3d3/2 and Ag 3d5/2, respectively (Phuruangrat et al., 2021). The intensities of the diffraction peaks tended to be increase with increasing Ag metal content. However, no characteristic Ag peak was observed in the 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl sample, which may be because of the low content of Ag.
3.1.3. Optical and electrochemical properties
The UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectroscopy results for the Bi3O4Cl and Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts are shown in Figure 5A. The maximum optical absorption wavelength of pure Bi3O4Cl is approximately 540 nm. The series of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts exhibited absorption at all visible wavelengths from 500 to 800 nm, which increased with increasing Ag content. This result indicates that the Ag metal on the surface of Bi3O4Cl undergoes a plasmon resonance phenomenon under visible-light irradiation, which greatly increases its light absorption ability and broadens its light absorption range. From the plot of (αhv)1/2 versus energy (hv) (Liu et al., 2017), the band gap of the Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst was determined to be 2.38 eV (Figure 5B). These results indicate that the Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst has superior visible-light absorption ability, which is beneficial for the utilization of sunlight.
(A) UV–Vis diffuse reflection spectrum (DRS), (B) bandgap energies, (C) photoluminescence (PL) spectra, (D) EIS Nyquist plots, and (E) TPRs of the investigated catalysts.
As shown in Figure 5C, the photoluminescence (PL) peak intensities of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl samples are weaker than those of Bi3O4Cl, indicating that the introduction of Ag reduced the electron-hole recombination rate of the photocatalyst. As the Ag content increased, the PL peak intensity of the samples gradually decreased. This is because excessive Ag metal hinders electron-hole pairs recombination and promotes carrier migration (Jiang et al., 2020).
The migration, conversion, and separation of electron-hole pairs in the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts were evaluated using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and transient current response (TPR). A smaller arc radius of the Nyquist curve of the photocatalyst indicates faster charge transfer. The trend of the influence of the Ag content on the radius of the curved arc is consistent with that of the PL spectrum and also presents a gradually decreasing trend (Figure 5D). The photocurrent response of the photocatalyst (Figure 5E) exhibited a gradually increasing trend as the Ag content increased. This result is consistent with the PL and EIS results, indicating that the presence of Ag metal promotes the migration, conversion, and separation of the electron-hole pairs of Bi3O4Cl (Hong et al., 2023).
Based on the optical and electrochemical characteristics of the photocatalysts, it can be concluded that the Ag content significantly affects the photoelectric performance of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts; with the increase in Ag content, the recombination of photogenerated electron-hole pairs is reduced, and the migration and separation capabilities of electrons and holes are enhanced, which is conducive to improving the performance of photocatalysts. However, in the photocatalytic oxidation of pollutants, the active substance that still plays the main role is Bi3O4Cl, and the presence of excessive Ag reduces the number of active sites of Bi3O4Cl, which may hinder the catalytic degradation of pollutants (Chen et al., 2014).
According to the above research, the morphology of Bi3O4Cl does not change after Ag deposition. Ag content affects the photoelectric performance of Bi3O4Cl, and an appropriate concentration of Ag can maximize the catalytic activity of Bi3O4Cl.
3.2. Performance of Ag-Bi<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>Cl photocatalyst toward EC degradation3.2.1. Applicability of Ag-Bi<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>Cl for CIP and TBBPA removal
As discussed in section “3.1. Characterization of photocatalysts,” Ag addition changes the physical and chemical properties of Bi3O4Cl, which in turn affects its catalytic activity. In this section, the applicability of Ag-Bi3O4Cl toward the removal of CIP and TBBPA (as the target contaminants) is verified by analyzing the degradation performance of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalysts with different Ag loadings.
As shown in Figures 6A, C, the adsorption capacities of the different photocatalysts for both CIP and TBBPA are ranked as follows: 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl > 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl > 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl > 0.1-Ag-Bi3O4Cl > Bi3O4Cl. Moreover, a single Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst had a poor effect on the treatment of ECs. After 210 min, the removal rate of pure Bi3O4Cl for CIP was only 51.4%, whereas after 120 min, the removal rate of TBBPA was only 36.0%.
Ciprofloxacin (CIP) and TBBPA removal in different photocatalysts: (A) removal efficiency of CIP; (B) kinetics of CIP removal; (C) removal efficiency of TBBPA; (D) kinetics of TBBPA removal; conditions: the concentration of CIP and TBBPA = 10 mg/L, initial pH, catalyst dosage = 0.8 g/L.
In comparison, the effect of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts on the treatment of CIP and TBBPA was better than that of single Bi3O4Cl, but the effect of samples prepared with different Ag contents was still different. For samples (0.01–0.1)-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, their photocatalytic degradation efficiencies for CIP were 75.2, 92.0, 87.3, and 54.1% after 210 min, respectively. After 120 min, their photocatalytic degradation efficiencies of TBBPA were 71.5, 90.5, 83.4, and 56.5%, respectively. As shown in Figures 6B, D, 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl exhibits the highest degradation rates of CIP (0.0107 min–1) and TBBPA (0.0165 min–1). The degradation of CIP/TBBPA was 1.8/2.2, 1.2/1.3, 3.7/3.6, and 3.5/3.6 times higher than those of 0.01-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, 0.05-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, 0.1-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, and Bi3O4Cl, respectively.
These results indicate that the efficiency of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalyst prepared by adding an appropriate amount of Ag to treat ECs in the water is much higher than that of a single Bi3O4Cl photocatalyst. Moreover, during the preparation process, the variation in the Ag metal content affected the photocatalytic performance of Ag-Bi3O4Cl, which showed a trend of increasing and then decreasing with increasing Ag metal content.
Based on the characterization analysis results discussed in section “3.1. Characterization of photocatalysts,” the Ag content significantly affects the photoelectric performance of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts. The increase in Ag content reduces the recombination of photogenerated electron-hole pairs and enhances the migration and separation capabilities of electrons and holes, which is conducive to improving the performance of the photocatalyst. However, the active substance that plays the main role in the photocatalytic oxidation of pollutants is Bi3O4Cl. Excessive Ag metal content reduced the number of Bi3O4Cl active sites, which hindered the catalytic degradation of pollutants. Therefore, it is necessary to select an appropriate Ag content. The experiments described in this section show that 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl is the optimal ratio.
3.2.2. Effect of catalyst dosage and solution pH on EC removal
We were selected that 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl was used to study the effects of the photocatalyst dosage and reaction pH on the degradation of CIP and TBBPA. As shown in Figure 7, when the dosage of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl was increased from 0.4 to 1.0 g/L, the adsorption performance, removal efficiency, and reaction rate constant of CIP and TBBPA gradually increase with the increase of the catalyst dosage. This is because by adding more photocatalyst, more active sites were obtained, thus improving the adsorption and catalytic efficiency of CIP and TBBPA. Moreover, the dosage of 0.8 g/L of photocatalyst is sufficient to fully degrade CIP and TBBPA. Therefore, considering both cost and degradation efficiency, a catalyst dosage of 0.8 g/L was selected as the optimal dosage condition in this study, and 0.8 g/L is selected for the following experiments.
Removal efficiency of CIP and TBBPA by 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl with different catalyst dosages: (A) removal efficiency of CIP; (B) kinetics of CIP removal; (C) removal efficiency of TBBPA; (D) kinetics of TBBPA removal.
In addition, the effect of the initial pH of the pollutants on the photocatalyst degradation was studied. As shown in Figure 8, the photocatalysts were effectively degraded both CIP and TBBPA in weakly acidic and alkaline environments. When the initial pH of CIP and TBBPA is in a weak alkaline environment, 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl exhibited the optimal adsorption and degradation effects (CIP: 93.8%; TBBPA: 94.9%) and the highest reaction rate constants (CIP: 0.02259 min–1; TBBPA: 0.0195 min–1). In contrast, the adsorption and treatment effects of the photocatalyst on pollutants are significantly reduced under strongly acidic conditions. Some studies have shown that the solubility of CIP is significantly affected by pH and can form cationic, anionic, or amphoteric species, which mainly depends on its different pKa (6.1 and 8.7) (Mao et al., 2016). Among them, amphoteric CIP ions have the lowest solubility and highest hydrophobicity, which results in a higher adsorption of CIP on the photocatalyst when the pH is between 6.1 and 8.7, thus indirectly improving the reaction rate. When the pH is higher than the TBBPA pKa (∼7.4), the degradation and debromination rates of TBBPA also increase sharply with an increase in pH, which contributes to easier degradation of TBBPA (Han et al., 2016). This also indicates that the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalyst can adsorb and remove CIP and TBBPA in both weakly acidic and alkaline environments, which is a good practical application.
Removal efficiency of CIP and TBBPA by 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl with different initial pH values of solution: (A) removal efficiency of CIP; (B) kinetics of CIP removal; (C) removal efficiency of TBBPA; (D) kinetics of TBBPA removal.
3.2.3. Reusability and stability of Ag-Bi<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>Cl
A reusability test of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl was performed; the results are shown in Figure 9. In Figure 9A, the SEM image of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl shows that its morphology did not change significantly before and after the reaction (Figure 2). Bi3O4Cl as the substrate is well preserved, and no Ag aggregation is observed on the photocatalyst surface. Figure 9B shows the XRD patterns of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl before and after the reaction, wherein the diffraction peaks are in the same position and the intensities remain unchanged, indicating that the photocatalyst has good stability.
(A) SEM images of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl after use; (B) the XRD patterns of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl before and after use; reusability of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl in (C) CIP and (D) TBBPA degradation.
Figures 9C, D show the photocatalytic degradation results of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl in five cycles. The CIP and TBBPA removal rates reach 70.6 and 71.2%, respectively, after five utilization cycles, suggesting the good reusability of the photocatalyst.
3.3. Photocatalytic mechanisms3.3.1. Radical quenching experiments and total organic carbon removal
To explore the reaction mechanism of the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalyst system, radical-quenching experiments were conducted on the free radicals generated in the catalytic system (Figure 10).
(A) Effects of various scavengers on the photocatalytic degradation of CIP; (B) effects of various scavengers on the photocatalytic degradation of TBBPA.
The addition of TBA, as a quencher of ⋅OH, had only a slight effect on the 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA, indicating that ⋅OH did not play a decisive role in the photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA (Jiang et al., 2018).
The addition of SO, as a quencher of h+, significantly inhibited the 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalytic degradation of both CIP and TBBPA. This result indicated that h+ was the active species that played a dominant role in the photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA. This is because of the high valence-band (VB) position of Ag-Bi3O4Cl, and h+ can directly oxidize organic pollutants (Long et al., 2022a).
The addition of BQ, as a quencher of ⋅O2–, also had a significant inhibitory effect on the photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA by 0.025-Ag Bi3O4Cl. This is due to the plasmon resonance phenomenon of Ag metal elements with light illumination, which greatly promotes the separation of electron-hole pairs and the generation of ⋅O2–, which can effectively oxidize and decompose pollutants in water (Li F. et al., 2014).
From the above results, it is clear that photo-generated holes (h+) and superoxide radicals (⋅O2–) play the dominant role in the photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA.
The photocatalytic degradation of CIP and TBBPA using total organic carbon (TOC) was investigated. After 210 min (CIP) and 120 min (TBBPA) of visible light irradiation, the removal rates of TOC reached 40.7 and 47.2%, respectively. Further removal of these intermediates was achieved by increasing the reaction time. These results indicate that the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts are effective for the treatment of ECs and exhibit good pollutant mineralization ability.
3.3.2. Degradation pathways of CIP and biotoxicity analysis of intermediate products
The intermediates of CIP photodegradation on 0.025-Ag Bi3O4Cl were detected by LC-MS (Supplementary Figure 2 and Supplementary Table 1). Based on these fragments and previous reports, two different degradation pathways were inferred in Figure 11 (Dewitte et al., 2008; Gao et al., 2021). In pathway I, CIP was attacked by the strong oxidizing radical and deoxygenated to produce the product P2 (m/z = 318). Next, the piperazine ring was broken and the ternary ring was further damaged by oxidation to produce products P3 (m/z = 274), P6 (m/z = 149), and P8 (m/z = 74). In pathway II, CIP was attacked by the oxide species and substituted with hydroxyl groups to generate product P4 (m/z = 298). Next, the C-N bond of the piperazine ring was broken and the ternary ring is removed, producing intermediate P5 (m/z = 183) and through a series of cleavage processes intermediates P7 (m/z = 103), P8 (m/z = 74) were generated. Finally, the above intermediate products could be decomposed into CO2 and H2O.
Suggested photocatalytic degradation pathways of CIP.
The biological toxicity of CIP degradation products was analyzed using EPI-ECOSAR software. There were two possible pathways for the degradation of CIP by 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts, namely CIP-P2-P3-P6-P8 and CIP-P4-P5-P7-P8. As shown in Supplementary Table 2, the biotoxicity of the intermediate products of CIP showed a trend of first significantly increasing in toxicity and then gradually decreasing. The biotoxicity of some intermediate products (P3 and P5) were much higher than that of CIP. Therefore, more attention should be paid to the detection of biotoxicity of degradation products in the treatment of ECs.
3.3.3. Possible mechanism of CIP and TBBPA removal over Ag-Bi<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>Cl
To illustrate the mechanism of the Ag metal-modified Bi3O4Cl at the electronic structure level, the flat band potential (EFB) of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl was measured using Mott–Schottky plots. As shown in Figure 12A, the negative slope of the tangent line in the Mott–Schottky plot of 0.025-Ag Bi3O4Cl, which is a typical p-type semiconductor (Abe et al., 2015), indicates that the introduction of Ag metal did not change the semiconductor type of Bi3O4Cl. The flat band potential (EFB) of 0.025-Ag Bi3O4Cl was 2.56 eV [2.76 eV versus normal hydrogen electrode (NHE)]. The EVB position of the p-type semiconductor is close to its EFB potential, which is approximately positive for EFB (0.1 eV) (Zheng and Lei, 2018). From this, it can be seen that in this work, the corresponding potential of EVB of 0.025-Ag Bi3O4Cl is approximately 2.86 eV versus NHE. Figure 12B shows the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS)-VB spectrum of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl, and the potential difference between VB of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl and its Fermi energy level is 1.81 eV as can be seen from the figure. Moreover, according to the formula ECB = EVB - Eg (Long et al., 2020c) and UV-vis results (The bandwidth Eg for Bi3O4Cl is 2.38 eV), the ECB and EVB value of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl were calculated as 0.48 and 2.86 eV, respectively (Figure 12C).
(A) Mott–Schottky plots of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl; (B) valence band (VB) XPS spectra of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl; (C) structural shifts of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalyst; (D) possible mechanism of Ag-Bi3O4Cl degrading ECs.
Based on the above analysis and related literature reports (Ma et al., 2015), potential photocatalytic mechanisms involving electron migration pathways and the catalytic degradation of pollutants by Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts were proposed (Figure 12D). During the photocatalytic reaction, the charge carriers in the VB of Bi3O4Cl were excited by visible light. When Ag metal is deposited on the surface of Bi3O4Cl, it increases the concentration of oxygen defects, resulting in the formation of an intermediate energy level in the semiconductors (Pan and Heagy, 2019). In addition, the plasmon resonance effect generated by the Ag metal under illumination greatly increased the light absorption ability of the photocatalyst (Shi et al., 2018). The coexistence of oxygen defects and Ag metals promotes electron transfer (Gao et al., 2014). Moreover, before Bi3O4Cl was modified, its electrons were directly excited from the VB to the conduction band (CB), making it prone to electron-hole pair recombination. In contrast, after plasmon modification, the electron migration path of the photocatalyst shifts to the intermediate energy level formed by Ag-Bi3O4Cl, where electrons from the VB in Bi3O4Cl are first excited, and then some of them are stored by Ag metal. Another part of the electron transitions from the Ag metal to the CB of Bi3O4Cl, which greatly hinders the probability of electron-hole recombination and can effectively improve the performance of the photocatalyst. Since the redox potential of O2/⋅O2– is −0.33 eV, which is more negative than the CB position of 0.025-Ag-Bi3O4Cl (0.48 eV), it is theoretically impossible to generate ⋅O2–. However, due to the plasmon resonance effect of Ag metal, the electrons excited to the CB of Bi3O4Cl via Ag metal can react with O2, thus generating ⋅O2– free radicals, which is consistent with the phenomenon reported by Jiang et al. (2018). The carrier charge separation led to the generation of a large number of h+ ions in the VB of Ag-Bi3O4Cl. And the h+ can also react with water to generate strong oxidizing radicals ⋅OH. Finally, the generated h+, ⋅O2–, and ⋅OH have strong oxidation ability, gradually degrading emerging contaminants into small molecule organic compounds, CO2, and H2O.
The potential reaction process for the Ag-Bi3O4Cl photocatalytic degradation of the ECs is shown in Eqs. (1–7).
In this study, a series of Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalysts were synthesized using a photodeposition method and characterized in detail. The introduction of Ag does not alter the morphology of Bi3O4Cl. With an increase in the Ag content, the oxygen defects on the photocatalyst surface first increase and then decrease. An appropriate Ag content of Ag-Bi3O4Cl can effectively enhance the photoelectric performance. The presence of Ag and oxygen defects promote the electron transfer in the photocatalyst. Under the optimal conditions (Ag content: 0.025, catalyst dosage: 0.8 g/L, and solution pH: 9), the Ag-Bi3O4Cl plasmonic photocatalyst can remove 93.8% of CIP and 94.9% of TBBPA, under visible light. Photogenerated holes (h+) and superoxide radicals (⋅O2–) are strongly oxidative radicals that play major roles in the photocatalytic reactions. The CIP degradation pathway was analyzed; the biological toxicity of CIP degradation products showed a trend of first increasing and then decreasing. In this study, a green, and stable plasmonic photocatalyst was developed and applied for the efficient removal of ECs from water and the biological toxicity of the degradation products was analyzed.
Data availability statement
The original contributions presented in this study are included in the article/Supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding authors.
Author contributions
ZL: conceptualization, methodology, and writing—original draft preparation. TG: data curation, investigation, and validation. CC: data curation and validation. GZ: supervision, visualization, investigation, writing—review, and editing. JZ: visualization, writing—review and editing, and funding acquisition. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.
Funding
This work was supported by the Science and Technology Innovation Project of Colleges and Universities in Shanxi Province (2022L361), the Youth Scientific Research Project of Shanxi Basic Research Program (202203021222311), the Doctoral Research Foundation of Changzhi Medical College (BS202204), the Project of Shenzhen Science and Technology Innovation Commission (No. KCXFZ20211020163817025), and the University-level Supporting Projects by Shenzhen polytechnic (No. 6020320003K).
We thank Shiyanjia Lab (www.shiyanjia.com) for the material testing service.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Publisher’s note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Supplementary material
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2023.1210790/full#supplementary-material
ReferencesAbeT.TannoY.TairaN.NagaiK. (2015). Efficient organo-photocatalysis system of an n-type perylene derivative/p-type cobalt phthalocyanine bilayer for the production of molecular hydrogen from hydrazine.RSC Adv.546325–46329. 10.1039/C5RA03842AApelgrenP.AmorosoM.SäljöK.MonteliusM.LindahlA.Stridh OrrhultL. (2019). Reversibly tuning the surface state of Ag via the assistance of photocatalysis in Ag/BiOCl.Nanotechnology30:305601. 10.1088/1361-6528/ab192e30986768BiC.CaoJ.LinaH.WangY.ChenS. (2016). Applied catalysis B : environmental enhanced photocatalytic activity of Bi12O17Cl2 through loading Pt quantum dots as a highly efficient electron capturer.Appl. Catal. B, Environ.195132–140. 10.1016/j.apcatb.2016.05.011ChangF.WangX.LuoJ.WangJ.XieY.DengB. (2017). Ag/Bi12O17Cl2 composite: a case study of visible-light-driven plasmonic photocatalyst.Mol. Catal.42745–53. 10.1016/j.molcata.2016.11.028ChenY.HuangW.HeD.SituY.HuangH. (2014). Construction of heterostructured g-C3N4/Ag/TiO2 microspheres with enhanced photocatalysis performance under visible-light irradiation.ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces614405–14414. 10.1021/am503674e25089850CuiP.WangJ.WangZ.ChenJ.XingX.WangL. (2016). Bismuth oxychloride hollow microspheres with high visible light photocatalytic activity.Nano Res.9593–601. 10.1007/s12274-015-0939-zCuiZ.DongX.SunY.ZhouY.ZhangY.DongF. (2018). Simultaneous introduction of oxygen vacancies and Bi metal onto the {001} facet of Bi3O4Cl woven nanobelts for synergistically enhanced photocatalysis.Nanoscale1016928–16934. 10.1039/C8NR05322G30178788DewitteB.DewulfJ.DemeestereK.Van De VyvereV.De WispelaereP.Van LangenhoveH. (2008). Ozonation of ciprofloxacin in water: HRMS identification of reaction products and pathways.Environ. Sci. Technol.424889–4895. 10.1021/es800068918678022GaoW.WangM.RanC.YaoX.YangH.LiuJ. (2014). One-pot synthesis of Ag/r-GO/TiO2 nanocomposites with high solar absorption and enhanced anti-recombination in photocatalytic applications.Nanoscale65498–5508. 10.1039/c3nr05466g24730025GaoY.CongS.YuH.ZouD. (2021). Investigation on microwave absorbing properties of 3D C@ZnCo2O4 as a highly active heterogenous catalyst and the degradation of ciprofloxacin by activated persulfate process.Sep. Purif. Technol.262:118330. 10.1016/j.seppur.2021.118330HanS. K.YamasakiT.YamadaK. (2016). Photodecomposition of tetrabromobisphenol A in aqueous humic acid suspension by irradiation with light of various wavelengths.Chemosphere147124–130. 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2015.12.07226766023HongY. Z.YangL.TianY. W. (2023). Rational design 2D/3D MoS2/In2O3 composites for great boosting photocatalytic H2 production coupled with dye degradation.J. Taiwan Inst. Chem. E.146:104862. 10.1016/j.jtice.2023.104862HouW.LiuZ.PavaskarP.HungW. H.CroninS. B. (2011). Plasmonic enhancement of photocatalytic decomposition of methyl orange under visible light.J. Catal.277149–153. 10.1016/j.jcat.2010.11.001JiangE.LiuX.CheH.LiuC.DongH.CheG. (2018). Visible-light-driven Ag/Bi3O4Cl nanocomposite photocatalyst with enhanced photocatalytic activity for degradation of tetracycline.RSC Adv.837200–37207. 10.1039/C8RA07482H35557788JiangR.LuG.NkoomM.YanZ.WuD.LiuJ. (2020). Mineralization and toxicity reduction of the benzophenone-1 using 2D/2D Cu2WS4/BiOCl Z-scheme system: simultaneously improved visible-light absorption and charge transfer efficiency.Chem. Eng. J.400:125913. 10.1016/j.cej.2020.125913JiangR.LuG.YanZ.WuD.LiuJ.ZhangX. (2019). Enhanced photocatalytic activity of a hydrogen bond-assisted 2D/2D Z-scheme SnNb2O6/Bi2WO6 system: highly efficient separation of photoinduced carriers.J. Colloid Interface Sci.552678–688. 10.1016/j.jcis.2019.05.10431176051KleinE.Milkowska-ShibataM.TsengK.SharlandM.GandraS.PulciniC. (2020). Assessment of WHO antibiotic consumption and access targets in 76 countries, 2000-15: an analysis of pharmaceutical sales data.Lancet Infect. Dis.21107–115. 10.1016/S1473-3099(20)30332-732717205LawR.AllchinC.BoerJ.CovaciA.HerzkeD.LepomP. (2006). Levels and trends of brominated flame retardants in the European environment.Chemosphere64187–208. 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2005.12.00716434081LiF.WangQ.WangX.LiB.HaoY.LiuR. (2014). In-situ one-step synthesis of novel BiOCl/Bi24O31Cl10 heterojunctions via self-combustion of ionic liquid with enhanced visible-light photocatalytic activities.Appl. Catal. B Environ.150–151574–584. 10.1016/j.apcatb.2014.01.009LiJ.ZhangL.LiY.YuY. (2014). Synthesis and internal electric field dependent photoreactivity of Bi3O4Cl single-crystalline nanosheets with high {001} facet exposure percentages.Nanoscale6167–171. 10.1039/C3NR05246J24217387LiuY.ZhuG.GaoJ.ZhuR.HojamberdievM.WangC. (2017). A novel synergy of Er3+/Fe3+co-doped porous Bi5O7I microspheres with enhanced photocatalytic activity under visible-light irradiation.Appl. Catal. B Environ.205421–432. 10.1016/j.apcatb.2016.12.061LiuZ. H.DangZ.YinH.LiuY. (2021). Making waves: improving removal performance of conventional wastewater treatment plants on endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs): their conjugates matter.Water Res.188:116469. 10.1016/j.watres.2020.11646933011607LongZ.LiQ.WeiT.ZhangG.RenZ. (2020a). Historical development and prospects of photocatalysts for pollutant removal in water.J. Hazard. Mater.395:122599. 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.12259932302881LongZ.XianG.ZhangG.ZhangT.LiX. (2020b). BiOCl-Bi12O17Cl2 nanocomposite with high visible-light photocatalytic activity prepared by an ultrasonic hydrothermal method for removing dye and pharmaceutical.Chinese J. Catal.41464–473. 10.1016/S1872-2067(19)63474-1LongZ.ZhangG.WeiT.NiuL.ZhuJ.LiJ. (2020c). Tuning of BixOyCl formation with sonication time during ultrasound-hydrothermal preparation.J. Ind. Eng. Chem.84322–331. 10.1016/j.jiec.2020.01.014LongZ.SongH.ZhangG.GaoJ.ZhuJ. (2022a). Fabrication of Bi-Bi3O4Cl plasmon photocatalysts for removal of aqueous emerging contaminants under visible light.J. Environ. Sci.11887–100. 10.1016/j.jes.2021.08.02635305776LongZ.WangH.HuangK.ZhangG.XieH. (2022b). Di-functional Cu2+-doped BiOCl photocatalyst for degradation of organic pollutant and inhibition of cyanobacterial growth.J. Hazard. Mater.424:127554. 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2021.12755434736196MaL.SunT.CaiH.ZhouZ. Q.SunJ.LuM. (2015). Enhancing photocatalysis in SrTiO3 by using Ag nanoparticles: a two-step excitation model for surface plasmon-enhanced photocatalysis.J. Chem. Phys.143:084706. 10.1063/1.492991026328866MaoD.YuA.DingS.WangF.YangS.SunC. (2016). One-pot synthesis of BiOCl half-shells using microemulsion droplets as templates with highly photocatalytic performance for the degradation of ciprofloxacin.Appl. Surf. Sci.389742–750. 10.1016/j.apsusc.2016.07.178Morin-CriniN.LichtfouseE.FourmentinM.RibeiroA. R. L.NoutsopoulosC.MapelliF. (2022). Removal of emerging contaminants from wastewater using advanced treatments. a review.Nanotechnology30:305601.NiuL.XianG.LongZ.ZhangG.ZhouN. (2020a). MnCeOx/diatomite catalyst for persulfate activation to degrade organic pollutants.J. Environ. Sci.89206–217. 10.1016/j.jes.2019.09.02031892392NiuL.XianG.LongZ.ZhangG.ZhuJ.LiJ. (2020b). MnCeOX with high efficiency and stability for activating persulfate to degrade AO7 and ofloxacin.Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf.191:110228. 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2020.11022831982684PanH.HeagyM. D. (2019). Plasmon-enhanced photocatalysis: Ag/TiO2 nanocomposite for the photochemical reduction of bicarbonate to formic acid.MRS Adv.4425–433. 10.1557/adv.2018.677PhuruangratA.ThongtemT.ThongtemS. (2021). Microwave-assisted deposition synthesis, characterization and photocatalytic activities of UV-light-driven Ag/BiOCl nanocomposites.Inorg. Nano-Metal Chem.511813–1821. 10.1080/24701556.2020.1855198ShiC.DongX.WangX.MaH.ZhangX. (2018). Ag nanoparticles deposited on oxygen-vacancy-containing BiVO4 for enhanced near-infrared photocatalytic activity.Chinese J. Catal.39128–137. 10.1016/S1872-2067(17)62990-5SunM.ZhangW.SunY.ZhangY.DongF. (2019). Synergistic integration of metallic Bi and defects on BiOI: enhanced photocatalytic NO removal and conversion pathway.Chinese J. Catal.40826–836. 10.1016/S1872-2067(18)63195-XWangH.XiH.XuL.JinM.ZhaoW.LiuH. (2021). Ecotoxicological effects, environmental fate and risks of pharmaceutical and personal care products in the water environment: a review.Sci. Total Environ.788:147819. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.14781934029823WangX.LiuX.LiuG.ZhangC.LiuG.XuS. (2019). Rapid synthesis of BiOCl graded microspheres with highly exposed (110) facets and oxygen vacancies at room temperature to enhance visible light photocatalytic activity.Catal. Commun.130:105769. 10.1016/j.catcom.2019.105769XinpingL.TaoH.FuqiangH.WendengW.JianlinS. (2006). Photocatalytic activity of a Bi-based oxychloride Bi3O4Cl.J. Phys. Chem. B11024629–24634. 10.1021/jp065373m17134224XuX.YanQ.GuX.LuoY. (2019). The preparation and photocatalytic performance of BiOCl@Ag, a visible-light responsive catalyst.J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Electron.308892–8902. 10.1007/s10854-019-01217-zYuC.CaoF.LiG.WeiR.YuJ. C.JinR. (2013). Novel noble metal (Rh, Pd, Pt)/BiOX(Cl, Br, I) composite photocatalysts with enhanced photocatalytic performance in dye degradation.Sep. Purif. Technol.120110–12210.1016/j.seppur.2013.09.036ZhangD.TanG.WangM.LiB.DangM.WangY. (2020). The formation of direct Z-scheme Ag/BiOCl/AgIO3 heterojunction and its degradation stability.Appl. Surf. Sci.530:147228. 10.1016/j.apsusc.2020.147228ZhangL.LiangC.GuoH.NiuC. G.ZhaoX. F.WenX. J. (2019). Construction of a high-performance photocatalytic fuel cell (PFC) based on plasmonic silver modified Cr-BiOCl nanosheets for simultaneous electricity production and pollutant removal.Nanoscale116662–6676. 10.1039/C8NR09616C30896684ZhaoL.DengJ.SunP.LiuJ.JiY.NakadaN. (2018). Nanomaterials for treating emerging contaminants in water by adsorption and photocatalysis: systematic review and bibliometric analysis.Sci. Total Environ.6271253–1263. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.02.00630857090ZhengJ.LeiZ. (2018). Incorporation of CoO nanoparticles in 3D marigold flower-like hierarchical architecture MnCo2O4 for highly boosting solar light photo-oxidation and reduction ability.Appl. Catal. B Environ.2371–8. 10.1016/j.apcatb.2018.05.060ZouP.LiZ.JiaP.LuoG.WangC. (2021). Enhanced photocatalytic activity of bismuth oxychloride by in-situ introducing oxygen vacancy.Colloids Surfaces Physicochem. Eng. Asp.623:126705. 10.1016/j.colsurfa.2021.126705