Front. Med.Frontiers in MedicineFront. Med.2296-858XFrontiers Media S.A.10.3389/fmed.2023.1092030MedicineOriginal ResearchModeling the effectiveness of One Health interventions against the zoonotic hookworm Ancylostoma ceylanicumWalkerMartin12*LambertSébastien123NevesM. Inês12WorsleyAndrew D.4TraubRebecca4ColellaVito4*1Department of Pathobiology and Populations Sciences, Royal Veterinary College, Hatfield, United Kingdom2Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, London Centre for Neglected Tropical Disease Research, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom3IHAP, INRAE, ENVT, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse, France4Department of Veterinary Biosciences, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Edited by: Serena Cavallero, Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
Reviewed by: Mehdi Borhani Zarandi, Jilin University, China; Joel Henrique Ellwanger, Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
*Correspondence: Martin Walker mwalker@rvc.ac.ukVito Colella vito.colella@unimelb.edu.ac
This article was submitted to Infectious Diseases: Pathogenesis and Therapy, a section of the journal Frontiers in Medicine
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
Hookworm disease is a major global public health concern, annually affecting 500–700 million of the world's poorest people. The World Health Organization is targeting the elimination of hookworm as a public health problem by 2030 using a strategy of mass drug administration (MDA) to at-risk human populations. However, in Southeast Asia and the Pacific the zoonotic hookworm species, Ancylostoma ceylanicum, is endemic in dogs and commonly infects people. This presents a potential impediment to the effectiveness of MDA that targets only humans. Here, we develop a novel multi-host (dog and human) transmission model of A. ceylanicum and compare the effectiveness of human-only and “One Health” (human plus dog) MDA strategies under a range of eco-epidemiological assumptions. We show that One Health interventions—targeting both dogs and humans—could suppress prevalence in humans to ≤ 1% by the end of 2030, even with only modest coverage (25–50%) of the animal reservoir. With increasing coverage, One Health interventions may even interrupt transmission. We discuss key unresolved questions on the eco-epidemiology of A. ceylanicum, the challenges of delivering MDA to animal reservoirs, and the growing importance of One Health interventions to human public health.
Hookworms are one of the three major soil-transmitted helminths (STHs)—alongside roundworms and whipworms—that collectively affect more than 2 billion people globally, causing significant morbidity (1). Hookworms alone were associated with approximately 1 million disability adjusted life years in 2019, the highest health burden of the three STHs (2). Like Ascaris lumbricoides (roundworm) and Trichuris trichiura (whipworm), hookworms are targeted by the World Health Organization (WHO) for elimination as a public health problem by 2030 using a strategy of so-called preventive chemotherapy (3). This entails annual or biannual mass administration of anthelmintics to at-risk populations, principally children and women of reproductive age who are at greatest risk of significant morbidity (1).
In Africa and the Americas, hookworm disease is predominantly caused by the anthroponotic species Necator americanus and Ancylostoma duodenale [but see (4)]. Therefore—in the absence of significant exogenous sources of infection—repeated treatment of human populations at sufficient frequency, coverage and adherence can, in theory, engender elimination (5–7). However, in Southeast Asia and the Pacific, the zoonotic species Ancylostoma ceylanicum—which globally infects approximately 100 million people—is the second most common cause of hookworm infection in humans (8–10). Dogs and cats are the main animal hosts of A. ceylanicum, and provide a substantial reservoir of infection to humans (11–13). The presence of a large untreated reservoir of infection presents a serious challenge to the elimination of hookworms in these regions and an impediment to reaching the WHO 2030 goals.
Numerous authors have advocated the use of a “One Health” approach to tackle A. ceylanicum hookworm (9–11, 14, 15) and indeed the WHO 2030 road map acknowledges the importance of One Health for other NTDs such as rabies, taeniasis, and cystic echinococcosis (1). Such an approach would likely involve expansion of mass drug administration (MDA) to domestic and stray cat and dog populations in settings where A. ceylanicum is endemic (15), similar to proposals to tackle zoonotic schistosomiasis in Africa by treating livestock (16, 17) and the existing strategy in China where animals are recognized as key to eliminating Schistosoma japonicum (18). Although there exist a number of highly efficacious treatment options for hookworm in cats and dogs—including “spot-on” topical treatments (19–21)—there is currently no empirical evidence on the likely effectiveness of a One Health approach.
In this paper, we develop a novel multi-host transmission dynamics model to compare the effectiveness of a One Health intervention strategy (that targets treatment of both humans and animals) with the current human-only MDA strategy. Motivated by settings in Southeast Asia, where dogs are a major source of A. ceylanicum infection (11–13), we consider a range of eco-epidemiological conditions with humans as either “maintenance” hosts—capable of sustaining transmission in the absence of dogs—or non-maintenance, spillover hosts (22). We simulate the impact of MDA starting in 2023 through 2030, aligning to the WHO's elimination timeline (1), quantifying effectiveness in terms of reductions in infection prevalence, and the probability of interrupting transmission.
2. Materials and methods2.1. Multi-host transmission dynamics model
Here, we describe the salient features of the multi-host mathematical transmission model developed for this analysis. A complete derivation is given in the Supplementary material section 1.1 and parameter definitions and values are given in Table 1. Briefly, the rate of change in the mean number of hookworms in host i at time t, Wi(t), is given by
dWi(t)dt=∑j(μW+μj)Rei,jWj(t)-(μW+μi)Wi(t),
Parameter definitions and values.
Parameter
Definition
Value
Reference
R0
Basic reproduction number; average number of adult female Ancylostoma ceylanicum produced by a single female worm in the absence of density dependencies
U[1, 8]
This work
ω1, 1
Proportion of total transmission (R0) attributable to host 1 (dogs)
U[0.5, 1]
This work
ω2, 1
Weighting parameter controlling the proportion of inter-species transmission attributable to host 1 (dogs)
U[0.5, 1]
This work
k1*
Overdispersion of hookworms among host 1 (dogs) at endemic equilibrium
U[0.1, 1]
This work
k2*
Overdispersion of hookworms among host 2 (humans) at endemic equilibrium
U[0.1, 1]
This work
μ1
Per capita mortality rate of host 1 (dogs)
1/5 yr−1
μ2
Per capita mortality rate of host 2 (humans)
1/50 yr−1
μW
Per capita mortality rate of adult hookworms
2/3 yr−1
(23)
μL
Per capita mortality rate of hookworm larvae
2 yr−1
(23)
b
Severity of density-dependent constraints on hookworm fecundity
0.245
(24)
ϵ1
Efficacy of spot-on formulation of imidacloprid and moxidectin (Advocate®) in host 1 (dogs)
100%
(19)
ϵ2
Efficacy of single oral dose aldendazole in host 2 (humans)
90%
(25)
c1
Coverage of mass drug administration in host 1 (dogs)
25%, 50% and 75%
This work
c2
Coverage of mass drug administration in host 2 (humans)
75%
(26)
where μW is the per capita mortality rate of adult hookworms (such that 1/μW is the life expectancy; assumed equal in both hosts), μi and μj are the mortality rates of hosts i and j, respectively, and Rei, j are components of the effective reproduction number, Re, describing transmission in (recipient) host i from (donor) host j (i.e., where i = j corresponds to transmission between the same host species—“intra-species”—and i≠j to transmission between different host species—“inter-species”). The components Rei, j are given by
Rei,j=R0i,jΩ(Wj(t),kj(t),b)Φ(Wj(t),kj(t)),
where Ω(·) and Φ(·) denote (constraining) density-dependent fecundity (23, 24, 27) and (facilitating) mating probability functions (28, 29), respectively (see Supplementary material section 1.2). Note that parameter kj(t)—which (inversely) quantifies the degree of aggregation (overdispersion) of hookworms in host j (23)—is dynamic and increases after each treatment round due to imperfect adherence (30) (see Supplementary material section 1.3). The basic reproduction number, R0, is given by the dominant eigenvalue of the so-called K matrix of intra- and inter-species components, R0i, j (31, 32). We parameterize matrix K as
where ω1, 1 = 1−ω2, 2 is the proportion of total transmission (i.e., proportion of R0) attributable to host 1 and ω2, 1 = 1−ω1, 2 controls the proportion of inter-species transmission attributable to host 1 (which is a function of R0; see Figure 1).
Transmission dynamics model schematic. The mean number of Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworms at time t in host 1 (dogs) and host 2 (humans) is denoted W1(t) and W2(t), respectively, and the mean density of larvae in the environment by L(t). Transmission among and between dogs and humans is coupled by a single shared environment. Intra-species transmission is defined by the reproduction numbers R01, 1 and R02, 2, respectively (solid arrows). The proportion of total transmission—defined by R0—that is attributable to dogs is given by ω1, 1 = (1−ω2, 2). Inter-species transmission in dogs from humans is defined by R01, 2 and in humans from dogs by R02, 1 (broken lines). The proportion of inter-species transmission attributable to dogs is proportional to R0 for ω2, 1 = 1−ω1, 2 = 0.5 and proportional to R02 for ω2, 1 = 1.
2.2. Infection prevalence
The prevalence of infection is derived from assuming a negative binomial distribution of hookworms among hosts (23, 33), such that
Pi(t)=1−(1+Wi(t)/ki(t))−ki(t).
Note that we assume implicitly that prevalence is measured using a perfect diagnostic (i.e., 100% sensitivity and specificity). The “apparent” prevalence would be affected by imperfect sensitivity and specificity, although for PCR, both have been reported as very high (34, 35).
2.3. Parameter sampling
We considered R0, ω1, 1(= 1−ω2, 2), ω2, 1(= 1−ω1, 2), k1*, and k2* (where ki* is the degree of overdispersion at endemic equilibrium; see Supplementary material section 1.3) as likely highly variable among different endemic settings. We therefore sampled 10, 000 parameter sets from independent uniform distributions using a Latin hypercube approach (36). We restricted the sampling to settings where R0>1 [although note that because hookworms are obligate sexually reproducing parasites, R0 = 1 is not a threshold for persistence (37), and therefore some of the parameter sets did not yield stable endemic equilibrium] and where dogs contribute a majority to both total transmission and inter-species transmission (i.e., ω1, 1∈[0.5, 1] and ω2, 1∈[0.5, 1]; see Figure 1). The overdispersion parameters ki* were sampled from plausible ranges (23, 33) (Table 1).
2.4. Modeling interventions
We simulated human-only and human plus dog “One Health” MDA strategies for the 10,000 parameter sets reaching stable endemic equilibrium. For simplicity, we considered only settings without prior intervention (i.e., at endemic equilibrium). We simulated annual MDA for endemic prevalence in humans ≥20% and biannual MDA for prevalence ≥50% (26) starting in 2023 with a final treatment in 2030 (i.e., 8 or 16 annual or biannual rounds, respectively). We assumed that dogs were treated with a spot-on anthelminthic with ϵ1 = 100% efficacy (e.g., imidacloprid and moxidectin) (19) and humans with a single oral dose of albendazole, with efficacy ϵ2 = 90% (25). Coverage in dogs, c1, was varied between 25% and 75% and for humans, we assumed a coverage of c2 = 75%. We modeled treatment as killing instantaneously a proportion ciϵi of adult hookworms. Note that the model is not age-structured and thus does not capture age-associated variation in infection and transmission and that c2 = 75% should be considered as a nominally “high” coverage, but is not directly comparable to the 75% target coverage for at-risk groups (children aged 1–14 years and women 15–45 years) set by the WHO (26).
3. Results3.1. Endemic settings
We used our transmission dynamics model (see section 2.1 and the schematic in Figure 1) to simulate a variety of endemic settings by random sampling of parameters governing the intensity of transmission—defined by the basic reproduction number, R0—the contribution of dogs to total and inter-species transmission (determined by parameters ω1, 1 and ω2, 1) and the degree of parasite aggregation among hosts (k1* and k2*; see also Table 1). We considered only settings where dogs are majority contributors to total transmission (i.e., R01, 1>R02, 2) and inter-species transmission (which is a non-linear function of R0; Figure 2), and we restricted R0 < 8. These relaxed parameter restrictions resulted in the endemic prevalence in dogs ranging from 26 to 99% and in humans from < 1 to 100% (Figure 2A).
Endemic prevalence of Ancylostoma ceylanicum in dogs and humans simulated from the multi-host transmission dynamics model. Variation in prevalence (A) was generated by random sampling of parameters governing the basic reproduction number, R0, the contribution of dogs to total and inter-species transmission, ω1, 1 and ω2, 1, and the degree of parasite aggregation among hosts, k1* and k2*. The strength of association between infection prevalence in humans (B) and dogs (C) and parameters R0, ω1, 1, ω2, 1, k1*, and k2* is quantified by the partial rank correlation coefficient, PRCC (38). The simulated endemic state is characterized by the distribution of R01, 1, R01, 2, R02, 1, and R02, 2(D).
High prevalence in humans is driven principally by a high R0, and a low degree of parasite aggregation (higher k2*, Figure 2B; see also Section 2.2). Low prevalence is driven by an increased contribution of dogs to transmission (higher ω1, 1) and, to a lesser extent, by a decline in parasite aggregation among dogs (higher k1*) which lessens the severity of constraints on hookworm fecundity. Like in humans, prevalence in dogs is driven predominantly by R0 and the degree of parasite aggregation, k1* (Figure 2C). Less important is their contribution to total and inter-species transmission, ω1, 1 and ω2, 1, since in all settings dogs are assumed to be majority contributors to R0. The degree of parasite aggregation among humans, k2*, also has limited impact on prevalence in dogs due to the restrictions imposed on human to dog transmission (i.e., a minimum of 50% of inter-species transmission is assumed to be attributable to dogs; see Figure 1).
Overall, the simulated endemic settings capture a broad array of eco-epidemiological conditions. These range from dogs and humans both as “maintenance hosts”—generally defined by R01, 1>1 and R02, 2>1 (22, 39), although note that R0 = 1 is not a threshold of persistence for dioecious sexually reproducing macroparasites (37)—to dogs as sole maintenance hosts with infection in humans driven by zoonotic “spillover”—generally defined by R01, 1>1 and R02, 2 < 1 (Figure 2D). In particular, because parameter ω2, 1>0.5 permitted a disproportionate contribution of dogs to inter-species transmission (Figure 1), it was possible to capture significant spillover in humans even in low-intensity transmission settings. Hence, certain parameter sets can yield extremely low endemic prevalence in humans (Figure 2A).
3.2. Infection dynamics during interventions
We applied the current WHO guidelines on initiating MDA, simulating annual treatment in settings with an endemic prevalence in humans ≥20% and biannual treatment for prevalence ≥50% (26). We modeled only the prevalence of A. ceylanicum and therefore, in reality, MDA could be indicated when the prevalence of A. ceylanicum is < 20% in settings where other STH species are endemic. We also set the coverage of treatment in humans to the nominal target value of 75% (1) set by the WHO and thus the dynamics elicited by human-only (or the human component of One Health) MDA strategies can be viewed as a “best case” scenario.
In human-only treatment strategies, the prevalence dynamics often reach a “pseudo-equilibrium,” whereby transmission is suppressed but relatively stable for both annual (Figure 3A) and biannual (Figure 3C) MDA. In these circumstances—where the effective reproduction number, Re>1 (Figures 3B, D)—stopping MDA would result in resurgence.
Dynamics of Anyclostoma ceylanicum infection prevalence during 8 years of human-only mass drug administration (MDA) simulated using the multi-host transmission dynamics model. For illustration, parameter sets were selected that gave an endemic prevalence in humans of 25–30% (A) and 60–65% (C). The solid colored lines indicate the median prevalence of infection (from the sampled parameter sets) in dogs and humans (as indicated) during annual (A) or biannual (C) MDA at 75% coverage and the lighter shaded areas indicate the extent of the 5th and 95th percentiles. The associated effective reproduction numbers, Re, are shown in (B) and (D), the solid line indicating the median and the shaded gray area the 5th and 95th percentiles. Below the threshold Re = 1, transmission is interrupted and the parasite population tends to elimination.
When a One Health strategy is implemented and MDA is extended to include dogs (assumed to be delivered at the same frequency as indicated for humans), prevalence in both dogs and humans declines progressively toward 2030 (Figures 4A, C) and, on average, Re is suppressed below 1 (Figures 4B, D) indicating interruption of transmission. Note that scenarios in which only dogs are treated were not considered here but would likely—depending on the intensity of intra- and inter-species transmission—suppress prevalence more rapidly in humans than seen in dogs for the corresponding human-only treatment strategies shown in Figure 3.
Dynamics of Anyclostoma ceylanicum infection prevalence during 8 years of “One Health” (dog plus human) mass drug administration (MDA) simulated using the multi-host transmission dynamics model. For illustration, parameter sets were selected that gave an endemic prevalence in humans of 25–30% (A) and 60–5% (C). The solid colored lines indicate the median prevalence of infection (from the sampled parameter sets) in dogs and humans (as indicated) during annual (A) or biannual (C) MDA at 75% coverage in humans and 50% cover in dogs. The lighter shaded areas indicate the extent of the 5th and 95th percentiles. The associated effective reproduction numbers, Re, are shown in (B) and (D), the solid line indicating the median and the shaded gray area the 5th and 95th percentiles. Below the threshold Re = 1, transmission is interrupted and the parasite population tends to elimination.
3.3. Effectiveness of One Health interventions
The implementation of a One Health MDA strategy has a significantly greater effect on suppressing the prevalence of A. ceylanicum hookworm in humans (and in dogs) by the end of 2030 compared to human-only MDA (Figures 5A, B). In particular, reaching a coverage of more than 50% in dogs suppresses the prevalence in humans to below 1% in a majority of scenarios (Figure 5C). Moreover, reaching 75% coverage in dogs yielded high (≥75%) chances of interrupting transmission and achieving local elimination (Figure 5D).
Effectiveness of 8 years of human-only or “One Health” (human plus dog) mass drug administration (MDA) against Ancylostoma ceylanicum. Boxplots show the prevalence of A. ceylanicum in humans (A) and dogs (B) at endemic equilibrium in 2022 and after 8 years of MDA at the end of 2030. Human-only MDA is indicated by a coverage in dogs of 0% (lightest color), with the coverage in dogs for One Health MDA varied between 25% and 75% as indicated. The bottom panels show the percentage of parameter sets yielding a prevalence < 1% in humans (C) or interruption of transmission [elimination; Re < 1; (D)] by 2030 against the endemic prevalence in 2022. MDA was not simulated for an endemic prevalence in humans of < 20%.
4. Discussion
Ancylostoma ceylanicum is the second most common cause of hookworm infection in Southeast Asia and the Pacific (8–10), with substantial reservoirs of infection in dogs and cats (11, 12). Here, we have modeled the potential effectiveness of a One health intervention strategy that expands MDA beyond only humans to also target the zoonotic reservoir of infection. Reflecting the uncertain epidemiology of A. ceylanicum, we simulated a broad range of plausible eco-epidemiological settings involving a single animal reservoir (here, dogs, which are major source of A. ceylanicum infection in some regions of Southeast Asia). We show that even modest MDA coverage (between 25% and 50%, assuming perfect adherence and drug efficacy) of the animal host may substantially improve effectiveness compared to current human-only strategies. Even in highly endemic treatment-naive settings, 50% MDA coverage is likely to suppress the prevalence of A. ceylanicum to < 1% by 2030 and may also achieve local elimination of transmission.
Our results indicate that One Health interventions will be essential to reaching the WHO 2030 elimination goals (1) in many settings where A. ceylanicum is endemic (9–11, 14, 15). It is noteworthy that the current WHO elimination goals do not mention A. ceylanicum (rather, just the the two most globally common species A. duodenale and N. americanus) (1). This may reflect a recognition of the likely limitations of human-only MDA where A. ceylanicum is endemic or a simple oversight of the emerging importance of zoonotic hookworm in the Asia-Pacific region. Irrespective, our results show clearly that—even with optimistic assumptions of human MDA coverage—the prevalence of A. ceylanicum hookworm may remain stubbornly high by 2030 without a One Health approach.
Intuitively, it is unsurprising that where A. ceylanicum is endemic—and animals (dogs) are the dominant driver of transmission, as modeled here—targeting only humans is unlikely to be an effective intervention. Likewise, for hookworm in general, it is unsurprising that treating only school-age children is a sub-optimal strategy because of the typical age-infection profiles that continue to increase into adulthood (40). Modeling provides a formal quantitative framework with which to compare these assertions with alternatives [such as treating humans and animals, or treating whole communities rather than only school-age children (41–43)]. Hence, it is important that our results are viewed as illustrating the need and the potential effectiveness of One Health interventions, not as predictions. Indeed, we have deliberately used a highly simplified modeling framework (e.g., host demographic structure is omitted; only a single animal reservoir is considered) both to enhance analytical tractability and to avoid over-interpretation of the results.
There currently remains too much of the eco-epidemiology of A. ceylanicum that is unknown to entertain more predictive modeling approaches. In particular, we are unaware of any studies that have attempted to quantify the relative contribution of humans and animal hosts to transmission [such as those for zoonotic schistosomiasis (44, 45)], although the few studies collecting data from humans and animals in the same epidemiological setting suggest that human-to-human transmission is likely substantially less common than animal-to-human transmission (11, 12). Moreover, estimates of infection intensity—critical to understanding intra- and inter-species dynamics—have only relatively recently been developed, using quantitative PCR techniques that can be calibrated to more traditional parasitological measures (i.e., egg counts) to assist with interpretation (46–49), including the calculation of drug efficacy (15). Indeed, we could not model egg counts here [or the prevalence of “moderate” or “high” intensity infection (1, 26)] because of these unknowns.
The inability to model explicitly quantities relating to the elimination of hookworm as a public health problem [i.e, prevalence of “moderate” or “heavy” infections < 2% (1)] meant that we could not evaluate the likelihood of One Health MDA strategies reaching this goal. Nevertheless—and irrespective of whether this goal is feasible where A. ceylanicum is endemic—resurgence is a risk in any settings where transmission is not interrupted (50, 51). The challenge posed by untreated zoonotic reservoirs is analogous to the question of whether treating only at-risk human population groups (i.e., children and women of childbearing age) will be sufficient to achieve sustained elimination of STHs more generally (41, 42). While treating only at-risk groups may be sufficient to drive prevalence to very low levels by 2030, modeling has shown that stopping intervention will risk resurgence in many endemic settings (50, 51). Hence, it has been argued that without wider community coverage aimed at breaking transmission (6, 7, 42), sustained elimination could require continuation of intervention (i.e., MDA) almost indefinitely. Our results concord with this assertion; without One Health interventions that go beyond human hosts, sustained elimination of A. ceylanicum is unlikely.
The use of modeling to demonstrate the potential effectiveness of One Health interventions where A. ceylanicum is endemic is, of course, much easier than the myriad complexities associated with implementation. First, while being most common in Southeast Asia and the Pacific, the geographic extent of A. ceylanicum continues to expand with the increasing use of molecular methods that distinguish hookworm species. Indeed, A. ceylanicum has recently been identified for the first time in the Americas (52, 53). Second, diagnosis and geographical mapping relies on molecular PCR methods which are more costly and resource-intensive than traditional parasitological methods. Third, although topical (spot-on) anthelminthic formulations—which would be a highly practicable mode of treatment—are highly efficacious (19–21), they are also expensive, intended for the commercial market of pet owners. Hence, the implementation of MDA in impoverished communities would require low-cost procurement or donation.
It is also important to reiterate that the modeling presented here considers only settings where there is a single animal reservoir of infection that is relatively straightforward to target for intervention (MDA). Yet A. ceylanicum can be common among both dogs and cats (12). Consequently, the implementation of an effective One Health intervention would require identification of the main animal reservoirs of infection that contribute substantially to human infection. This would incur further resource overheads and logistical complexity to implementation. Indeed, if in our modeling framework we included both dogs and cats as equally contributing to infection in humans, but only the former were targeted for MDA, the effectiveness (and likely also the cost-effectiveness) of the intervention in reducing human infection would be greatly diminished. However, in a recent study performed across eight countries in Asia, hookworms were significantly higher in dogs than in cats, with implementation of educational programs deemed crucial for the control of zoonotic infections of companion animals in Asia (54). While MDA is the cornerstone of the WHO's strategy to eliminating STHs, other approaches such as improved water and sanitation (WASH), education and awareness, infrastructure development, and food safety are also advocated as complementary activities (1). Additionally, treatment of animals, vaccination, and animal husbandry and management practices (all under a One Health umbrella) are also specifically supported by the WHO in the context of other NTDs such as rabies, taeniasis, and echinococcosis. Hence, while the implementation of a One Health approach to tackle A. ceylanicum hookworm would undoubtedly present challenges, similar approaches are not without precedent for other NTDs.
5. Conclusions
Although A. ceylanicum has been recognized as a multi-host parasite since 1913, it has only been in the past decade that it has been recognized as of significant public health importance (4). This period has seen a great expansion in the use of molecular approaches that have blurred the lines of host specificity in other helminth species, including schistosomes (44, 55), and other STHs (56, 57). It is thus unquestionable that One Health approaches to tackling these neglected diseases will be increasingly emphasized as inroads are made into the human reservoirs of infection while animal reservoirs remain largely unchecked. We have shown that a One Health MDA strategy could be highly effective against A. ceylanicum hookworm in endemic regions of Southeast Asia and beyond and will be essential for sustained elimination and reaching the WHO 2030 goals. While there remain challenges to implementation—as well as significant gaps in knowledge on the eco-epidemiology of zoonotic hookworms—this work illustrates the potentially substantial impact of a One Health approach to improving human public health.
Data availability statement
The datasets presented in this study can be found in online repositories. The names of the repository/repositories and accession number(s) can be found below: The model code used for this analysis is publicly available at https://github.com/martwalker/zoonotic-hookworm.
Author contributions
MW, SL, and VC conceptualized the work. MW conducted the analysis and drafted the manuscript. MW, SL, and MN built the model. MW, SL, RT, and VC edited the manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Publisher's note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Supplementary material
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2023.1092030/full#supplementary-material
ReferencesWorld Health Organization. Ending the Neglect to Attain the Sustainable Development Goals – A Road Map for Neglected Tropical Diseases 2021–2030. Geneva: World Health Organization (2020).World Health Organization.The Global Health Observatory (2022). Available online at: https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/themes/mortality-and-global-health-estimates/global-health-estimates-leading-causes-of-dalys (accessed February 22, 2023).World Health Organization. Preventive Chemotherapy in Human Helminthiasis. Coordinated Use of Anthelminthic Drugs in Control Interventions: A Manual for Health Professionals and Programme Managers.Geneva: World Health Organization (2006).TraubRZendejas-HerediaPAMassettiLColellaV. Zoonotic hookworms of dogs and cats - lessons from the past to inform current knowledge and future directions of research. Int J Parasitol. (2021) 51:1233–41. 10.1016/j.ijpara.2021.07.00134748782TruscottJETurnerHCFarrellSHAndersonRM. Chapter Three - Soil-transmitted helminths: mathematical models of transmission, the impact of mass drug administration and transmission elimination criteria. Adv Parasitol. (2016) 94:133–98. 10.1016/bs.apar.2016.08.00227756454AndersonRMTruscottJHollingsworthTD. The coverage and frequency of mass drug administration required to eliminate persistent transmission of soil-transmitted helminths. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. (2014) 369:20130435. 10.1098/rstb.2013.043524821921TruscottJHollingsworthTDAndersonR. Modeling the interruption of the transmission of soil-transmitted helminths by repeated mass chemotherapy of school-age children. PLOS Negl Trop Dis. (2014) 8:e3323. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000332325474477ColellaVBradburyRTraubR. Ancylostoma ceylanicum. Trends Parasitol. (2021) 37:844–5. 10.1016/j.pt.2021.04.01334049804StrackeKJexARTraubRJ. Zoonotic ancylostomiasis: an update of a continually neglected zoonosis. Am J Trop Med Hyg. (2020) 103:64–8. 10.4269/ajtmh.20-006032342850TraubRJ. Ancylostoma ceylanicum, a re-emerging but neglected parasitic zoonosis. Int J Parasitol. (2013) 43:1009–15. 10.1016/j.ijpara.2013.07.00623968813InpankaewTSchärFDalsgaardAKhieuVChimnoiWChhounC. High prevalence of Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworm infections in humans, Cambodia, 2012. Emerg Infect Dis. (2014) 20:976–82. 10.3201/eid2006.13177024865815NguiRLimYALTraubRMahmudRMistamMS. Epidemiological and genetic data supporting the transmission of Ancylostoma ceylanicum among human and domestic animals. PLOS Neglect Trop Dis. (2012) 6:e1522. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000152222347515MahdyMLimYNguiRSiti FatimahMChoySYapN. Prevalence and zoonotic potential of canine hookworms in Malaysia. Parasit Vectors. (2012) 5:88. 10.1186/1756-3305-5-8822564445BradburyRSHiiSHarringtonHSpeareRTraubR. Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworm in the Solomon Islands. Emerg Infect Dis. (2017) 23:252–7. 10.3201/eid2302.16082228098526ColellaVKhieuVWorsleyASenevirathnaDMuthSHuyR. Risk profiling and efficacy of albendazole against the hookworms Necator americanus and Ancylostoma ceylanicum in Cambodia to support control programs in Southeast Asia and the Western Pacific. Lancet Reg Health West Pac. (2021) 16:100258. 10.1016/j.lanwpc.2021.10025834590062GowerCMVinceLWebsterJP. Should we be treating animal schistosomiasis in Africa? The need for a One Health economic evaluation of schistosomiasis control in people and their livestock. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. (2017) 111:244–7. 10.1093/trstmh/trx04729044372DiazAVLambertSNevesMIBorlaseALégerEDioufND. Modelling livestock test-and-treat: a novel One Health strategy to control schistosomiasis and mitigate drug resistance. Front Trop Dis. (2022) 3:893066. 10.3389/fitd.2022.893066HongZLiLZhangLWangQXuJLiS. Elimination of Schistosomiasis japonica in China: from the One Health Perspective. China CDC Wkly. (2022) 4:130–4. 10.46234/ccdcw2022.02435265392TaweethavonsawatPChungpivatSSatranarakunPTraubRJSchaperR. Experimental infection with Ancylostoma ceylanicum in dogs and efficacy of a spot on combination containing imidacloprid 10% and moxidectin 2.5% (Advocate/Advantage Multi, Bayer Animal Health).Parasitol Res. (2010) 106:1499–502. 10.1007/s00436-010-1819-920349196TaweethavonsawatPChaimeeTPriyavoravongPTraubRJ. Efficacy of single topical treatment of Selamectin (Revolution®) against Ancylostoma ceylanicum in experimentally infected cats. Vet Parasitol Reg Stud Rep. (2019) 18:100346. 10.1016/j.vprsr.2019.10034631796176KnausMTaweethavonsawatPCheesmanTVisserMRehbeinS. Efficacy of broadlineⓇ in cats against induced infections with developing fourth-stage larval and adult Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworms. Vet Parasitol. (2020) 277:100025. 10.1016/j.vpoa.2020.10002532904740NishiuraHHoyeBKlaassenMBauerSHeesterbeekH. How to find natural reservoir hosts from endemic prevalence in a multi-host population: a case study of influenza in waterfowl. Epidemics. (2009) 1:118–28. 10.1016/j.epidem.2009.04.00221352759AndersonRMMayRM. Infectious Diseases of Humans: Dynamics and Control.Oxford: Oxford University Press (1991).AndersonRMSchadGA. Hookworm burdens and faecal egg counts: an analysis of the biological basis of variation. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. (1985) 79:812–25. 10.1016/0035-9203(85)90128-23832493MoserWSchindlerCKeiserJ. Efficacy of recommended drugs against soil transmitted helminths: systematic review and network meta-analysis. Brit Med J. (2017) 358:j4307. 10.1136/bmj.j430728947636World Health Organization. Preventive Chemotherapy to Control Soil-Transmitted Helminth Infections in At-Risk Population Groups.Geneva: World Health Organization (2017).NevesMNGowerCMWebsterJPWalkerM. Revisiting density-dependent fecundity in schistosomes using sibship reconstruction. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2021) 15:e0009396. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000939633983965MayRM. Togetherness among schistosomes: its effects on the dynamics of the infection. Math Biosci. (1977) 34:301–43. 10.1016/0025-5564(77)90030-XMayRM. Biased sex ratios and parasite mating probabilities. Parasitology. (1993) 107:287–95. 10.1017/s00311820000792698233592CollyerBSAndersonRM. Probability distributions of helminth parasite burdens within the human host population following repeated rounds of mass drug administration and their impact on the transmission breakpoint. J R Soc Interface. (2021) 18:20210200. 10.1098/rsif.2021.020033906385DiekmannOHeesterbeekJAPMetzJAJ. On the definition and the computation of the basic reproduction ratio R0 in models for infectious diseases in heterogeneous populations. J Math Biol. (1990) 28:365–82. 10.1007/BF001783242117040DobsonA. Population dynamics of pathogens with multiple host species. Am Nat. (2004) 164:S64–78. 10.1086/42468115540143ShawDJDobsonAP. Patterns of macroparasite abundance and aggregation in wildlife populations: a quantitative review. Parasitology. (1995) 111:S111–33. 10.1017/S00311820000758558632918DunnJCPapaiakovouMHanKTChooneeDBettisAAWyineNY. The increased sensitivity of qPCR in comparison to Kato-Katz is required for the accurate assessment of the prevalence of soil-transmitted helminth infection in settings that have received multiple rounds of mass drug administration. Parasit Vec. (2020) 13:324. 10.1186/s13071-020-04197-w32580759PapaiakovouMPilotteNGrantJTraubRLlewellynSMcCarthyJ. A novel, species-specific, real-time PCR assay for the detection of the emerging zoonotic parasite Ancylostoma ceylanicum in human stool. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2017) 11:e0005734. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000573428692668TangB. Orthogonal array-based latin hypercubes. J Am Stat Assoc. (1993) 88:1392–7. 10.2307/2291282AndersonRTurnerHFarrellSTruscottJ. Studies of the transmission dynamics, mathematical model development and the control of schistosome parasites by mass drug administration in human communities. Adv Parasitol. (2016) 94:199–246. 10.1016/bs.apar.2016.06.00327756455MarinoSHogueIBRayCJKirschnerDE. A methodology for performing global uncertainty and sensitivity analysis in systems biology. J Theor Biol. (2008) 254:178–96. 10.1016/j.jtbi.2008.04.01118572196RobertsMGHeesterbeekJAP. Characterizing reservoirs of infection and the maintenance of pathogens in ecosystems. J Roy Soc Interf. (2020) 17:20190540. 10.1098/rsif.2019.054031937232HotezPJBrookerSBethonyJMBottazziMELoukasAXiaoS. Hookworm infection. N Engl J Med. (2004) 351:799–807. 10.1056/NEJMra03249215317893AndersonRMTurnerHCTruscottJEHollingsworthTDBrookerSJ. Should the goal for the treatment of soil transmitted helminth (STH) infections be changed from morbidity control in children to community-wide transmission elimination?PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2015) 9:e0003897. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000389726291538TruscottJHollingsworthTDBrookerSAndersonR. Can chemotherapy alone eliminate the transmission of soil transmitted helminths?Parasit Vectors. (2014) 7:266. 10.1186/1756-3305-7-26624916278CoffengLBakkerRMontresorAde VlasS. Feasibility of controlling hookworm infection through preventive chemotherapy: a simulation study using the individual-based WORMSIM modelling framework. Parasit Vectors. (2015) 8:541. 10.1186/s13071-015-1151-426489659BorlaseARudgeJLégerEDioufNFallCDiopS. Spillover, hybridization, and persistence in schistosome transmission dynamics at the human-animal interface. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2021) 118:e2110711118. 10.1073/pnas.211071111834615712RudgeJWebsterJLuDWangTFangGBasáñezM. Identifying host species driving transmission of schistosomiasis japonica, a multihost parasite system, in China. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. (2013) 110:11457–62. 10.1073/pnas.122150911023798418HiiSSenevirathnaDLlewellynSInpankaewTOdermattPKhieuV. Development and evaluation of a multiplex quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction for hookworm species in human stool. Am J Trop Med Hyg. (2018) 99:1186–93. 10.4269/ajtmh.18-027630226132LlewellynSInpankaewTNerySVGrayDJVerweijJJClementsACA. Application of a multiplex quantitative PCR to assess prevalence and intensity Of intestinal parasite infections in a controlled clinical trial. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2016) 10:e0004380. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000438026820626LeBClarkeNHiiSFByrneAZendejas-HerediaPALakeS. Using quantitative PCR to identify opportunities to strengthen soil-transmitted helminth control in Solomon Islands: a cross-sectional epidemiological survey. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2022) 16:1–17. 10.1371/journal.pntd.001035035604904Zendejas-HerediaPAColellaVHiiSFTraubRJ. Comparison of the egg recovery rates and limit of detection for soil-transmitted helminths using the Kato-Katz thick smear, faecal flotation and quantitative real-time PCR in human stool. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. (2021) 15:1–18. 10.1371/journal.pntd.000939534038411FarrellSHCoffengLETruscottJEWerkmanMToorJde VlasSJ. Investigating the effectiveness of current and modified World Health Organization guidelines for the control of soil-transmitted helminth infections. Clin Infect Dis. (2018) 66(Suppl_4):S253–9. 10.1093/cid/ciy00229860285NTD Modelling Consortium Discussion Group on Soil-Transmitted Helminths. Insights from quantitative analysis and mathematical modelling on the proposed WHO 2030 goals for soil-transmitted helminths. Gates Open Res. (2019) 3:1632. 10.12688/gatesopenres.13077.231819925SearsWCardenasJKubofcikJNutmanTCooperP. Zoonotic Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworm infections, Ecuador. Emerg Infect Dis. (2022) 28:1867–9. 10.3201/eid2809.22024835997627Zendejas-HerediaPColellaVMacphersonMSylvesterWGasserRMacphersonC. Ancylostoma ceylanicum hookworms in dogs, Grenada, West Indies. Emerg Infect Dis. (2022) 1870–2. 10.3201/eid2809.22063435997602ColellaVWongnakPTsaiY-LNguyenV-LTanDYTongKBY. Human social conditions predict the risk of exposure to zoonotic parasites in companion animals in East and Southeast Asia. Commun Med (Lond). (2022) 2:144. 10.1038/s43856-022-00210-836380151LegerEWebsterJ. Hybridizations within the Genus Schistosoma: implications for evolution, epidemiology and control. Parasitology. (2017) 144:65–80. 10.1017/S003118201600119027572906EastonAGaoSLawtonSPBennuruSKhanADahlstromE. Molecular evidence of hybridization between pig and human Ascaris indicates an interbred species complex infecting humans. eLife. (2020) 9:e61562. 10.7554/eLife.6156233155980Mohd-ShaharuddinNLimYALHassanNANathanSNguiR. Molecular characterization of Trichuris species isolated from humans, dogs and cats in a rural community in Peninsular Malaysia. Acta Trop. (2019) 190:269–72. 10.1016/j.actatropica.2018.11.02630500371