Edited by: Heidi Kloos, University of Cincinnati, United States
Reviewed by: Muhammad Kristiawan, University of Bengkulu, Indonesia
Erikson Saragih, University of North Sumatra, Indonesia
M. Habibi, Universitas Negeri Padang, Indonesia
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
This study introduces a multi-smart agent-based training environment aimed at enhancing the production of 3D graphics and fostering design-thinking skills among primary-stage computer teachers. This environment offers a collaborative and interactive learning experience using intelligent agents represented as animated characters. The research evaluates the effectiveness of this innovative training approach through experimental groups, demonstrating significant improvements in the cognitive and psychomotor domains of 3D graphics production skills and in developing design thinking. The results underscore the potential of smart agent technology in educational settings, offering a dynamic platform for teacher professional development by integrating modern technological tools and creative problem-solving methodologies. This study pioneers using multi-smart agent environments in primary education, providing a novel framework that significantly enhances educators' skills and prepares them for future technological advancements in teaching.
Enhancing teacher competencies, skills, and training is essential for improving educational outcomes globally. Teachers play a crucial role in nurturing innovative capabilities in students, which are fundamental to national competitiveness and progress (Abah,
In developed nations, there is significant emphasis on equipping educators with foundational skills through structured teacher preparation and in-service training programs (Robert,
Despite recognizing these needs, a considerable gap remains in effectively integrating educational technologies into teacher training programs. Traditional training methods often fail to provide educators with the practical skills needed to incorporate advanced technologies, particularly in computer education (Crompton and Burke,
Recent advancements in educational technology offer promising solutions to these challenges. Virtual training environments and intelligent agents have emerged as innovative tools that can transform teacher education by providing interactive and personalized learning experiences (Weber et al.,
This study addresses a critical problem in the current educational landscape: the inadequacy of existing training methodologies in effectively equipping primary-stage computer teachers with essential skills in 3D graphics production and design thinking. Current training programs often fail to leverage advanced technologies, such as intelligent agent environments, which offer interactive and personalized learning experiences that could bridge this gap.
The main objectives of this study are:
To design and implement a training environment based on a multi-smart agent model that enhances 3D graphics production skills among elementary computer teachers.
To foster design thinking skills in teachers through advanced virtual training tools.
To evaluate the effectiveness of the multi-smart agent training environment in improving computer teachers' cognitive and performance skills.
This study seeks to answer the following research questions:
This study makes several significant contributions to the fields of educational technology and teacher training:
This document is organized as follows: Section 2 provides a thorough review of relevant literature. Section 3 details the proposed model and its components. Sections 4 and 5 present the methods and the experimental results in a structured manner. Finally, Sections 6 and 7 summarize the essential findings and suggest directions for future research.
The enhancement of teachers' competencies, skills, and training is recognized as crucial in education systems worldwide, transcending the developmental status of countries. Teachers are pivotal in nurturing students' innovative capabilities, essential for national competitiveness (Abah,
In developed countries, equipping educators with essential skills has become a distinguishing feature of teacher preparation and in-service training programs. These initiatives aim to enhance teachers' capacities, allowing them to adapt to scientific advancements and foster the development of student's abilities (Al-Mozan,
Virtual training environments have emerged as a viable solution to the challenges associated with professional development. By leveraging virtual training, educators can enhance ongoing skills and improve productivity, organizational efficacy, and skill deficits (Abdul Rahman,
The design of virtual training environments should prioritize diversity and richness in methodologies and activities, facilitating trainee participation and interaction. A well-designed virtual environment guides trainees in organizing electronic information sources effectively, catering to varied learning styles and fostering effective engagement (Abu Al-Dahab,
Recent research has gained significant attention on integrating intelligent agents into virtual training environments. Intelligent agents enhance trainee integration, boost interactivity, and add dynamism to the training process (Bassiouni,
Intelligent agents exhibit various characteristics, including adaptation, asynchrony, flexibility, goal orientation, and cooperation (Nazir,
Research has highlighted the effectiveness of multi-directed intelligent agents in virtual training environments. These agents, represented as animated characters, function as collaborative guides, dividing training topics into tasks and assisting trainees in problem-solving (Kiourt et al.,
Furthermore, the 3D graphics approach in electronic content design has become a modern technology for teaching academic courses. Three-dimensional graphics enhance engagement and comprehension by providing a mathematical representation of objects that can be modified and rotated (Glick et al.,
The open-source SketchUp program will be employed in this research to produce three-dimensional drawings. This tool allows teachers to generate educational elements with realistic characteristics, enhancing immersion in the learning process. Design thinking, closely aligned with how designers think and work, offers a framework for experimenting with idea generation and fostering creativity (Mootee,
Design thinking emphasizes creative problem-solving methods and systems thinking, integral to understanding and addressing educational challenges (Iyad,
This section outlines the proposed model, which is designed to enhance 3D graphics production and foster design thinking among elementary school computer teachers. The model features animated, AI-powered characters. These intelligent agents simulate real-life tasks, provide step-by-step instructions, deliver immediate feedback, and assist in solving complex problems, thus offering a dynamic, interactive learning experience tailored to improve cognitive and practical skills.
The proposed model is built on a systematic approach integrating educational technology and interactive training environments. It leverages multi-smart agent technology to create a dynamic and engaging learning experience structured through the following key stages:
Establish a preliminary list of essential 3D graphics production skills tailored for primary-stage computer teachers.
Refine the skills list through expert evaluation, resulting in a comprehensive set of 6 main stages, 28 primary skills, and 12 sub-skills, encompassing 189 performance indicators.
2.
Create a detailed list of standards for designing the training environment, expressed in clear and measurable terms.
Adjust the list based on input from educational technology specialists, finalizing it with four main areas, 23 sub-criteria, and 274 sub-indicators.
3.
a.
Assess teachers' proficiency in internet usage, electronic device handling, and familiarity with web applications.
Ensure resource availability and obtain necessary approvals for the research experiment.
Conduct a cost-benefit analysis to outline the anticipated benefits of enhancing 3D graphics production skills and design thinking.
b.
Identify and address shortcomings based on teachers' experiences with the technology and the training environment.
Establish the technological infrastructure and determine the work team.
c.
Define general objectives for the training content and identify training needs.
Analyze resources and constraints and define responsibilities and tasks.
d.
Formulate procedural objectives and design training content.
Develop multimedia resources, interaction interfaces, and assessment tools.
Design scenarios and event boards to guide the training process.
e.
Produce multimedia content, training activities, and internal interactions.
Create a guide for using the training environment.
f.
Test the training environment and monitor results.
Implement final modifications based on feedback.
g.
Deploy the training environment in real-world settings.
Publish the environment for expanded use and register intellectual property rights.
Conduct the research experiment with the target group.
Introduction to agents: teachers are introduced to a set of intelligent agents, each designed to perform specific tasks related to 3D graphics. These agents serve as mentors, guiding the teachers through various learning objectives.
Interactive learning modules: teachers engage in interactive modules, where the agents demonstrate key concepts in 3D graphics production and design thinking. The agents also facilitate hands-on exercises, enabling teachers to apply the concepts they have learned.
Collaborative problem-solving: the agents assist teachers in solving complex design challenges by breaking down problems into manageable tasks. The agents encourage creative problem-solving by adapting to the teachers' performance and providing tailored support.
This study employed a quasi-experimental research design to investigate the effectiveness of a multi-smart agent-based training environment on enhancing both 3D graphics production and design thinking skills among primary school computer teachers. The study followed a mixed-methods approach, integrating both qualitative and quantitative data to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of the intervention. This approach is recommended for educational technology research where both objective skill assessments and subjective feedback are critical (Creswell and Creswell,
The participants in this study were selected using a purposive sampling technique, ensuring that the teachers chosen aligned with the study's objectives. A total of 60 primary school computer teachers from the Riyadh Educational Administration in Kafr El-Sheikh Governorate were included in the study. Specific inclusion criteria guided the selection process:
Both qualitative and quantitative data were used to ensure the study captured comprehensive insights into the effectiveness of the training intervention. The data types are described as follows:
To measure the effectiveness of the training environment, the following instruments were employed:
The data collection process was conducted in three phases:
Several steps were taken to ensure the credibility of the research findings:
The study utilized a one-group quasi-experimental design with pre-and post-test measurements to assess the impact of the independent variable on the research outcomes. This design was chosen because it effectively addresses the research objectives by allowing for the observation of changes attributable to the intervention.
Cognitive test construction
A cognitive achievement test was developed to evaluate participants' knowledge of 3D graphics production skills. The test initially contained 67 multiple-choice items. Educational technology experts reviewed the test to ensure its validity and reliability. The final version retained all 67 items, with each item contributing to a maximum total score of 67 points.
Psychomotor domain observation checklist
An observation checklist was created to assess psychomotor skills in 3D graphics production. Experts validated the checklist, which was finalized to include six main stages, 28 primary skills, 12 sub-skills, and 189 performance indicators. The checklist was designed to comprehensively evaluate the practical application of skills, resulting in a total possible score of 567 points.
Final product quality evaluative checklist
The evaluative checklist for the final product quality was developed to measure various aspects of 3D graphics production outcomes. It included 5 main areas, 13 sub-standards, and 130 evaluation indicators. This checklist was validated by experts to ensure it accurately reflects the quality standards expected in the field, with a total score of 260 points.
Design thinking scale
The Design Thinking Scale was initially crafted to measure participants' design thinking capabilities across 5 main dimensions and 40 statements. After expert feedback, the scale was refined to maintain its 5 dimensions and 40 sub-phrases, ensuring a comprehensive assessment of creative and analytical thinking skills.
Pre-administration of research instruments
The cognitive test and observation checklist were administered before introducing the training environment to establish baseline performance data.
Scores from these pre-tests were recorded for comparison with post-test results during statistical analysis.
Implementation of the research experiment
A preparatory session was held to brief the participating teachers on the training plan and objectives.
The main experimental phase occurred from February 18, 2023, to March 21, 2023, during which the intervention was applied.
Post-administration of research instruments
After completing the intervention, post-tests were administered, including the cognitive test, observation checklist, final product quality evaluative checklist, and design thinking scale.
These instruments measured the changes in knowledge, skills, and quality of work attributable to the intervention.
Data analysis was conducted using SPSS version 27. It involved statistical methods such as mean, standard deviation, percentages, and t-tests to evaluate the effectiveness of the interventions and quantify changes between pre-and post-test results. The analysis aimed to determine the significance and impact of the training environment on the participants' performance.
The research results can be presented as follows:
The first research question is: “What skills are needed to produce three-dimensional drawings for computer teachers in primary school?” The research procedures answer this question, and all the steps for preparing a 3D graphics production skills list are listed. In its final form, the list consists of 28 primary skills, 12 sub-skills, and 189 sub-performance indicators.
The second research question is: “What are the criteria for designing a training environment based on the multiple intelligent agent model to develop 3D graphics production skills among computer teachers in the primary stage?” The research procedures answered this question, and all the steps for preparing the list of standards were listed. In its final form, the list consisted of 4 main areas, 23 sub-criteria, and 274 sub-indicators.
The research procedures address the third sub-question regarding the educational design used in the training environment based on the multiple intelligent agent model, outlining the steps of educational design following Al-Desouki's (
The answer to the fourth sub-question, focusing on the effectiveness of the training environment in developing the cognitive aspect of 3D graphics production skills among computer teachers in the primary stage, will involve testing the validity of the first hypothesis. The hypothesis suggests a statistically significant difference at a substantial level of ≤ 0.05 between the mean scores of the first and second experimental groups in the post-application of the cognitive test in favor of the second experimental group. The cognitive test results for both groups will be statistically processed to validate this hypothesis. See
Results of teachers of both groups in the post-test administration.
| Total marks | 56.87 | 64.77 | 2.08 | 11.15 | 58 | 0.001 | |
To answer the fifth research question, which states: “What is the effectiveness of a training environment based on the multiple intelligent agent model in developing the performance aspect of 3D graphics production skills among computer teachers in the primary stage?” the validity of the second hypothesis of the research will be tested. The hypothesis stated: “There is a statistically significant difference at a significance level ≤ 0.05 between the average scores of the teachers of the first experimental group and the scores of the teachers of the second experimental group in the post-application of the observation card in favor of the second experimental group.” To test the validity of this hypothesis, the results of the two post-applications of the card were statistically processed. Observation for the two experimental groups, as shown in
Results of the two experimental groups in the post-administration of the observation checklist.
| Total marks | 482.53 | 6.29 | 514.97 | 6.09 | 41.51 | 58 | 0.001 |
The results in
The third research hypothesis was examined in response to the sixth research question regarding the effectiveness of a training environment based on the multiple intelligent agent model in enhancing the quality of the final product of 3D graphics production skills among primary-stage computer teachers. This hypothesis posited a statistically significant difference ( ≤ 0.05) between the average scores of the first and second experimental groups in the post-application of the final product quality assessment card, favoring the second experimental group. The statistical analysis of the post-application results of the final product quality evaluation card for both experimental groups is outlined in
Results of the two experimental groups in the post-application of the assessment card.
| Total marks | 218.43 | 4.18 | 251.13 | 4.22 | 51.00 | 58 | 0.001 |
It is evident from the data presented in
Focusing on the effectiveness of a training environment based on the multiple intelligent agent model in developing design thinking among computer teachers in the primary stage involved testing the validity of the third hypothesis. This hypothesis posited: “There is a statistically significant difference at a significance level of ≤ 0.05 between the average scores of the teachers of the first experimental group and the scores of the teachers of the second experimental group in the post-application of the design thinking scale in favor of the second experimental group.” The results of the post-application of the design thinking scale for the two experimental groups were subjected to statistical analysis to assess the validity of this hypothesis.
The analysis of
Comparison of test scores between the first and second experimental groups.
| Marks | 85.70 | 3.76 | 106.72 | 4.36 | 68.31 | 58 | 0.001 |
This study demonstrates the Multi-Smart Agent-Based Training environment's significant effectiveness in enhancing cognitive and psychomotor skills among elementary school computer teachers, specifically within the context of 3D graphics production and design thinking. The experimental results revealed statistically significant improvements in the performance of teachers who participated in the smart-agent-driven training compared to those in the control group. These improvements can be attributed to the interactive nature of the training, where the intelligent agents provided step-by-step instructions, immediate feedback, and practical assistance in solving complex tasks.
The study's results suggest that the intelligent agents' adaptive nature was critical in fostering practical skills and creative problem-solving capabilities. The intelligent agents tailored the learning process according to each teacher's progress, allowing personalized learning experiences that effectively addressed individual needs. This led to a noticeable increase in proficiency in 3D graphics production, facilitated by interactive engagement with real-world tasks rather than rote memorization. This finding underscores the strength of Multi-Smart Agent-Based Training in delivering content that is both accessible and intellectually challenging, leading to a deeper understanding and more hands-on mastery of the subject matter.
In addition to the technical skills, including design thinking principles within the training environment encouraged teachers to approach challenges creatively and critically. By applying innovative solutions to problems encountered during 3D graphics production, the teachers enhanced their technical proficiency and ability to think creatively. This combination of technical and cognitive skill development aligns well with the demands of modern educational environments, where teachers are expected to integrate technology and creative problem-solving into their instructional methods.
The results of this study are in agreement with previous research, such as Crompton and Burke (
The novelty of this research lies in its dual focus on enhancing technical proficiency in 3D graphics production and fostering design thinking among educators. While previous studies have demonstrated the ability of intelligent agents to improve cognitive outcomes, this study provides evidence that such environments can also enhance psychomotor skills and creative problem-solving abilities. This is particularly significant as combining these two skill sets is critical in preparing educators to meet the evolving needs of 21st-century education.
The significance of these findings is further underscored by their potential applications in teacher professional development programs. The results indicate that Multi-Smart Agent-Based Training can effectively train teachers in technical subjects, where hands-on skills and creative thinking are essential. By integrating intelligent agents into professional development programs, educational institutions can provide a dynamic and engaging learning experience that prepares teachers for the challenges of modern education.
However, this study has limitations. The sample size was relatively small, comprising only 60 participants from a specific educational administration, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the five-week duration of the training program may not have been sufficient to capture the long-term retention of skills. Future research could explore the impact of intelligent agents on skill retention over a longer period and across different educational contexts.
In conclusion, this study contributes valuable insights into the use of intelligent agent-based environments in teacher training, particularly for enhancing both technical and creative skills. The results demonstrate that intelligent agents can significantly improve cognitive and psychomotor skills, making them valuable tools in professional development programs. The findings also suggest the potential for expanding the application of such environments in other areas of education, ultimately helping educators integrate technology and innovative problem-solving approaches into their teaching practices.
The multi-smart agent-based training environment presents a novel and effective methodology for enhancing 3D graphics production skills and fostering design thinking among elementary school computer teachers. By integrating intelligent agents, this model provides a dynamic and adaptive learning experience that promotes cognitive development and technical proficiency. The findings from this study offer strong evidence that AI-powered agents significantly improve teachers' cognitive and psychomotor skills, enabling them to apply complex concepts with greater accuracy and creativity in practical scenarios.
This training environment addresses a critical gap in modern teacher education, particularly in technical domains like 3D graphics production, where traditional approaches often fall short. The intelligent agents effectively deepen the learning process and enhance engagement by offering immediate feedback and simulating real-world problem-solving scenarios. Furthermore, including design thinking in the training equips teachers with advanced technical skills and encourages innovative approaches to teaching and problem-solving in their classrooms.
Future research should aim to expand the application of this training model to a broader range of educational contexts. The intelligent agents must be refined to incorporate more advanced feedback mechanisms and simulate increasingly complex tasks. Additionally, exploring integrating collaborative learning and social interaction components within the agent-driven environment could further enhance its effectiveness, promoting cooperative learning and peer engagement among participants.
The multi-smart agent-based training environment has laid a robust foundation for the future of teacher education in technical fields. By advancing the functionality of intelligent agents and expanding the application of this model to diverse educational contexts, this approach holds significant potential to elevate teacher competencies and improve academic outcomes in an increasingly digital and technologically driven educational landscape.
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
The studies involving humans were approved by Riyadh Educational Administration in Kafr El-Sheikh Governorate. The studies were conducted in accordance with the local legislation and institutional requirements. The participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study. Written informed consent was obtained from the individual(s) for the publication of any potentially identifiable images or data included in this article.
SS: Writing – original draft, Software, Resources, Methodology, Funding acquisition. MA: Writing – review & editing, Resources, Methodology, Investigation. RA: Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Formal analysis, Data curation.
The author(s) declare financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. This work was supported by the Deanship of Scientific Research, Vice Presidency for Graduate Studies and Scientific Research, King Faisal University, Saudi Arabia, under Project Grant KFU241496.
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.