The generation of γ-ray beams dates back to Baldwin and Klaiber (1947), who generated a photon beam via the Bremsstrahlung process from a 100-MeV betatron accelerator. The Bremsstrahlung process, where electrons or other charged particles emit photons while decelerating in a dense matter, has remained one of the primary methods for producing the beams necessary for photodisintegration reaction studies throughout the decades. For a complete historical overview and a thorough discussion about current photonuclear topics, a review of the status and history of the field of photonuclear physics was recently published by Zilges et al. (2022). Here, we will focus on the aspects of (γ, n) cross-section measurements.

As the Bremsstrahlung beams are generated by slowing down, typically, electrons, the beams produced have some drawbacks regarding photonuclear cross-section measurements. While easy to produce, the energy spectra are extending as a modified power law from the lowest energy to the electron end-point energies. This property generates the risk of significant systematic uncertainties from the unfolding procedures necessary to have cross-sections at fixed energies. One method to overcome this problem is using high-energy positron beams (Colgate and Gilbert, 1953). While the generation becomes slightly more complex, the beam quality is improved by the annihilation peak of the positrons, giving rise to a quasi-monoenergetic beam on top of the Bremsstrahlung background. This method was developed in the two laboratories in Livermore (Fultz et al., 1962) and Saclay (Beil et al., 1969). There has been a longstanding discussion about discrepant results between Livermore and Saclay, both using the same method to generate the beams. The discrepancy is illustrated in Figure 1 and discussed in detail by Varlamov et al. (2017) and in the recent review by Kawano et al. (2020).

To generate monoenergetic γ-ray beams, the method of laser Compton backscattering (LCS) was introduced by Milburn (1963) and Arutyunian and Tumanian (1963). Here, a relativistic electron beam of a given energy collides with laser photons of a given frequency, and the backscattered photons will take a significant part of the electron kinetic energy with an energy-dependent angular distribution. Selecting specific angles through a collimator, the photon beams will have a well-defined energy and a narrow bandwidth, significantly reducing systematic measurement uncertainties, illustrated in Figure 1. This beam type will be the primary source of γ rays at ELI-NP.

Finally, another method under development is based on accelerating the primary electrons using laser wakefield acceleration from high-power lasers, a technology that will be the second main pillar of the ELI-NP facility via the 100 TW, 1 PW, and 10 PW beam lines (Tanaka et al., 2020). Such a measurement on p-process nuclei, namely the ⁹²Mo(γ,n)^91m,gMo isomeric ratios and the ⁹²Mo (γ, 3n)⁸⁹Mo reaction was recently reported by Wu et al. (2023).

Mechanisms of neutron detection are based on indirect methods since neutrons do not carry any charge. These mechanisms are based on neutron scattering or neutron absorption by detection media leading to the production of secondary particles, which can produce ionization around the interaction point. Typically neutron detectors to study (γ, n) reactions rely on the neutron capture process due to their almost 4π angular coverage and high efficiency. The neutron capture cross-section is usually higher for the thermal energy neutron range. Therefore, neutron counters are typically embedded in moderator material. The first neutron counters developed of this type represented boron neutron detectors surrounded by a water tank. More modern and nowadays systems commonly exploit ³He or BF₃ gas-filled counters placed inside a paraffin or high-density polyethylene matrix. Different quenching gas, for example, CO₂ or Ne, are often used to enhance the counting characteristics. However, due to the moderation process, precise information on the individual neutron energy is lost. This problem is solved by designing the system with flat neutron detection efficiency in a broad neutron energy range (Utsunomiya et al., 2017). Another method of neutron counting is based on (semi)activation techniques. The total number of emitted neutrons can be estimated by counting γ-rays emitted by the daughter nucleus. However, the method requires information on the absolute γ-ray transition intensities, thus, representing an additional source of systematic errors. It also limits the possible cases that can be measured to isotopes with levels with strong γ-ray emission either following β decay or population of isomeric states.

This section will overview the existing photonuclear data of the p-process nuclei. We will limit the discussion to pure (γ, n) data and not include, except in exceptional cases, measurements of, for example, isomeric ratios and higher order channels like (γ, 2n). Table 1 summarises the most recent data sets for an accessible overview of the current state-of-the-art.

The lightest p-process nuclei ⁷⁴Se and ⁸⁴Sr isotopes have been measured once using Bremsstrahlung from the Betatron at Saratov State University in Russia with a BF₃ counter setup by Goryachev and Zalesnyy (1982). In the case of ⁹²Mo, this is one of the most well-studied p-process nuclei, where cross-section, integrated cross-section, and cross-section ratio measurements have been performed. The first data set on the photoneutron cross-section curve and integrated cross-section have been measured by residual activity method using the Tohoku University 25 MeV betatron Bremsstrahlung gamma rays by Mutsuro et al. (1959). The second data set is by Ishkhanov et al. (1970) using Bremsstrahlung from the Betatron at Moscow State University, in the range of 12.2 MeV and 26.8 MeV, using BF₃ detectors. The third data set for the cross-section of ⁹²Mo and also ⁹⁴Mo were obtained by the positron annihilation in-flight of monochromatic positions from the 60 MeV linear accelerator at Saclay in by Beil et al. (1974) and Carlos et al. (1974) using their gadolinium-loaded liquid scintillator tank setup in the range of 12.53–29.47 MeV. In a recent measurement, the cross sections for the (γ, n) reaction have again been measured using Bremsstrahlung photons from an electron accelerator and determined using the gamma-activation method (Ishkhanov et al., 2014) at the end-point energies of 19.5, 29.1, and 67.7 MeV at Moscow State University.

The ⁹⁴Mo(γ,n) reaction has been investigated with quasi-monochromatic LCS photon beams both at TERAS in Japan (Utsunomiya et al., 2013), and HIγS facility of the Triangle Universities Nuclear Laboratory (TUNL) by Banu et al. (2019) in the range of 9.9–11.78 MeV and 9.7–13.5 MeV, respectively. The data obtained data all cases (Beil et al., 1974; Utsunomiya et al., 2013; Banu et al., 2019) are in good agreement below 10.8 MeV photon energies. However, above that, energy results of Banu et al. (2019) start to deviate from the Beil et al. (1974) and Utsunomiya et al. (2013) data when the contribution to the measured cross sections from neutrons emitted from excited states that γ decay to the ground state in ⁹³Mo. Note that neither Utsunomiya et al. (2013) or Banu et al. (2019) had a flat-efficiency neutron detector but relied on the ring-ratio method (Utsunomiya et al., 2013) or Geant4 simulations of the possible branching channels (Banu et al., 2019) to infer the efficiency. Thus, the flat-efficiency ELIGANT-TN detector could provide an interesting complementary data set also here.

Cross sections have been measured for (γ,n) reactions of ⁹⁶Ru, ⁹⁸Ru, and ¹⁰²Pd by Tickner et al. (2010) and Skakun et al. (2013). The first measurement used Bremsstrahlung radiation with end-point energies of 11–14 MeV using the activation technique in the Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency in Melbourne, Australia. The second measurement was performed to determine the integral cross-section using Bremsstrahlung beams at the electron linear accelerator of Kharkiv Institute of Physics and Technology (KIPT) and the Microtron of Uzhgorod National University in Ukraine with different end-points in the range of 10.85–14 MeV (Skakun et al., 2013). The cross-section of ¹⁰⁸Cd has been measured with the induced-activity method by using a beam of Bremsstrahlung radiation with end-point energy of 55 MeV at the racetrack microtron RM-55 by Belyshev et al. (2014) at the Lebedev Physical Institute in Moscow. The cross-section of the of ¹¹³In(γ,n)^112mIn reaction has been measured in the Bremsstrahlung end-point energy range between 10 and 13 MeV by activation using the ¹⁹⁷Au(γ,n)¹⁹⁶Au reaction cross section as a reference standard by Skakun et al. (2016) at KIPT and the Uzhgorod National University.

For the ¹¹²Sn and ¹¹⁴Sn, the only direct experimental data available is from Bremsstrahlung experiments from Moscow State University by Sorokin and Yurev (1975) and Sorokin et al. (1972), respectively, using BF₃ detectors. In the ¹¹⁴Sn case, the target had a relatively low isotopic purity with only 65.1%. Additionally, these data sets have been evaluated by Varlamov et al. (2010) extracting cross-section curves based on the theoretical modelling of cross-section ratios. However, model-independent direct measurements would be desirable.

The population of isomeric states in the isotopes ¹³⁰Ba and ¹³²Ba has been measured twice using Bremsstrahlung beams and the activation method, once at the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR) in Dubna (Belov et al., 1996b; Thiep et al., 2012) and once at Uzhgorod National University (Mazur and Bigan, 2001), with consistent results. However, no exclusive cross-section that populates ground-state to ground-state data can be found. One case highlighted in the work by Camera et al. (2016) is ¹³⁸La, with a natural abundance of 0.089%. This isotope has been out of reach from experimental measurements with previous facilities and is systematically problematic in p-process calculations as it is consistently underproduced in all p-process scenarios. Here, the destruction cross-section, ¹³⁸La (γ, n)¹³⁷La is of fundamental importance as it determines the balance between the ¹³⁹La (γ, n)¹³⁸La production, whose ground state cross section is known (Utsunomiya et al., 2006b), and destruction. The activation method was used for ¹³⁶Ce with Bremsstrahlung beams at Uzhgorod National University by Mazur et al. (2019) providing data in the energy range 10.5–18 MeV. For ¹³⁸Ce, no absolute (γ, n) cross sections are available, only isomeric ratios (Belov et al., 1996a; Palvanov and Razhabov, 1999; Goryachev and Zalesnyy, 2001; Thiep et al., 2009; Mazur et al., 2016) from JINR in Russia, KIPT and Uzhgorod National University in Ukraine, and the SB-50 Betatron of the National University of Uzbekistan; and an estimation of the total cross-section from Dietrich and Berman (1988) used by Belov et al. (1996a).

One of the nuclei that have recent LCS measurements available is ¹⁴⁴Sm, which was remeasured by Filipescu et al. (2014) using LCS and a ³He neutron detector. In this measurement, a systematic reduction of the cross-section with 20% was found compared to the previous data set by Carlos et al. (1974) from Saclay, as shown in Figure 1, based on positron annihilation in-flight with a gadolinium-loaded scintillator tank, and highlights the importance of also remeasuring existing data with new methods.

For the remaining heavy nuclei, the data is increasingly sparse. The ¹⁵²Gd isotope has been measured once using Bremsstrahlung from the Betatron at Saratov State University in Russia with 12 proportional counters by Goryachev and Zalesnyy (1982). There is only one integrated data point each available for ¹⁵⁶Dy, ¹⁵⁸Dy (Vagena and Stoulos, 2017b), and ¹⁶²Er Vagena and Stoulos (2017a), in the energy range 9.1–14 MeV obtained via Bremsstrahlung at the University Hospital in Larissa, Greece. A similar situation occurs for ¹⁶⁸Yb, where two integrated Bremsstrahlung cross sections were measured at 10 MeV and 15 MeV end-point energies by Bholane et al. (2022) at Dr. Vikhe Patil Memorial Hospital, Ahmednagar, India, and in the energy range 9.1–14 MeV by (Vagena and Stoulos, 2018), using the activation technique. Also, in this case, systematic measurements would be desirable.

The isotope ¹⁸⁰Ta, identified in the studies by Camera et al. (2016) as one of the flagship cases for studies with ELIGANT-TN at ELI-NP, is unique in this case due to the extreme rarity of the element and the existence of a long-lived isomeric state with a significantly longer lifetime than the ground state. Thus, in the ^179−181Ta network, there are eight different production and destruction reactions, in addition to the thermalization equilibrium between ^180mTa and ^180gTa, see for example the discussion by Belic et al. (1999), Belic et al. (2002); Schlegel et al. (2016). Of these, the ¹⁸¹Ta (γ, n)¹⁸⁰Ta (Utsunomiya et al., 2003) and the ^180mTa (n, γ)¹⁸¹Ta (Wisshak et al., 2001) are measured, as well as the isomeric ratios in the ¹⁸¹Ta (γ, n)¹⁸⁰Ta reaction (Goko et al., 2006). Measurements of ^180mTa (γ, n)¹⁸¹Ta is challenging due to the natural abundance of the target being only 0.012% and, thus, very high-intensity γ-ray beams with well-defined energies to reduce the uncertainties related to subtraction of, for example, Bremsstrahlung spectra and high-efficiency neutron detector systems are critical. However, also here it is important to note that this ground-state cross-section will only provide a lower limit of the astrophysical rate due to the dominating contributions of thermally excited states (Mohr et al., 2007; Hayakawa et al., 2010a; Hayakawa et al., 2010b) and the main impact will be constraining theoretical models.

For ¹⁸⁰W, only the isomeric ratios have been measured by Demekhina et al. (2002) at the synchrotron facility using the activation technique at the Yerevan Physics Institute in Armenia. For ¹⁹⁰Pt, the stellar reaction rates have been simulated by a superposition of Bremsstrahlung measurements at different energies by Vogt et al. (2001) and the threshold reaction cross-section has been measured from a Bremsstrahlung spectrum at the Superconducting-DArmstadt-LINear-ACcelerator (S-DALINAC) using the activation techniqe with high-purity germanium detectors by Mohr et al. (2000). For ¹⁹⁶Hg, isomeric ratios have been measured by Thiep et al. (2019) with Bremsstrahlung at JINR, and the threshold reaction cross-section has been measured by the same method as ¹⁹⁰Pt at the S-DALINAC by Sonnabend et al. (2004).